Ornstein: Former Forest man leading contender for the role | OneFootball

Dyche leads Forest shortlist for managerial vacancy

Forest’s managerial carousel continues

Nottingham Forest’s turbulent campaign has taken another twist, with Sean Dyche emerging as the frontrunner to take charge following the dismissal of Ange Postecoglou. According to David Ornstein in The Athletic, the club’s hierarchy, led by global head of football Edu and technical director George Syrianos, have held positive meetings with Dyche as they continue their exhaustive search for stability.

Photo IMAGO

Dyche’s name carries weight within Premier League circles. With almost a decade’s worth of top-flight experience across Burnley and Everton, he represents a pragmatic choice for a side short on consistency and confidence. Ornstein also reports that Forest have spoken to Roberto Mancini, though a return to English football now appears unlikely, while Marco Silva remains committed to Fulham.

Dyche’s credentials appeal to Forest’s hierarchy

Forest’s decision-makers are said to value Dyche’s familiarity with English football and his proven ability to work within financial and structural limitations. During his spell at Everton, he guided the club through turbulent waters, keeping them in the Premier League despite two separate points deductions for PSR breaches.

Photo: IMAGO

His tenure at Burnley remains his most enduring success story, where he secured six straight Premier League seasons and a Europa League qualification that represented a golden chapter in the club’s modern history. It is that sense of resilience and identity that may now appeal most to Forest, who have cycled through multiple managers without finding cohesion.

Postecoglou departure leaves Forest in turmoil

Postecoglou’s short-lived spell came to an end after a bruising 3-0 home defeat to Chelsea, capping a winless eight-match run. The Australian’s record of one point from five league fixtures underscored a broader sense of drift. Defeats to Arsenal, Sunderland, Newcastle and Chelsea, along with cup and European setbacks, left the hierarchy with little choice.

Photo IMAGO

Forest sit 18th in the Premier League and must now rebuild swiftly ahead of their Europa League meeting with Porto. For Dyche, if appointed, it would represent a return to the touchline that once defined his grit and organisation.

Our View – EPL Index Analysis

The thought of Sean Dyche in the dugout may feel both reassuring and uninspiring for Forest fans. His record for structure, discipline and survival is undeniable, yet the Forest’s issues run deeper than defensive frailties or tactical misfires. Supporters may question whether Dyche represents a step forward or simply a return to a firefighting mentality that has defined Forest’s modern identity.

There is admiration for his resilience, but fans crave ambition beyond 17th place. Dyche’s Everton sides were sturdy but seldom expressive, and at Burnley, his success was built on simplicity and physicality rather than flair. With Forest investing heavily in technical talent, from creative midfielders to European prospects, supporters could wonder whether Dyche’s methods align with the squad’s potential.

Many will recall the optimism that surrounded Postecoglou’s appointment, and though his reign faltered, it symbolised a desire for progressive football. A Dyche era would likely deliver stability, but perhaps at the cost of style and excitement. For fans still dreaming of Forest reclaiming a measure of their historic prestige, that might not feel enough.