Paul Joyce: Liverpool star set to turn down potential January move | OneFootball

Paul Joyce Update Leaves Liverpool Star’s Future Uncertain

Liverpool’s midfield depth and long term planning have once again become a major talking point after fresh reporting placed Harvey Elliott’s future under renewed scrutiny. The Liverpool loanee, currently at Aston Villa, remains in a situation that has frustrated supporters and left the parent club unable to intervene, despite clear sporting and financial implications.

Paul Joyce Confirms Harvey Elliott Stance

Paul Joyce of The Times has reported that Harvey Elliott will not take up interest from MLS despite being left in limbo as his season continues to stall. The update contradicts growing claims that a short term move to the United States, specifically to MLS, could provide an exit ramp for the Liverpool midfielder.

Interest from clubs including Charlotte FC had been genuine, with Fabrizio Romano previously noting that Charlotte were prepared to offer a loan until June, subject to Elliott’s approval. However, Joyce has clarified that the 22 year old is not contemplating that route, preferring to remain in England while waiting for clarity from Villa. Crucially, the report also states that Elliott will not be returning to Liverpool either.

Liverpool Frozen Out of Recall Possibilities

From Liverpool’s perspective, the situation has become increasingly delicate. Liverpool have no recall option written into the Villa agreement, meaning the club cannot terminate or redirect the loan, even though the player has been frozen out of Unai Emery’s squad since 2 October.

Villa’s agreement includes an appearance based obligation to convert the loan into a £35 million permanent transfer, understood to include a £5 million loan fee, should Elliott reach 10 senior appearances. He remains stuck on five, a threshold he has not added to since early autumn, leaving the transfer clause dormant and his development pathway unclear.

Photo: IMAGO

Joyce further reports that there has been no contact from Villa regarding a change of plan, and no discussions have taken place over early termination. With the season passing without progression, Liverpool’s hands remain tied.

Harvey Elliott Future Impact on Liverpool Planning

The lack of movement would be easier to digest if Liverpool had not recently emphasised the importance of retaining strong midfield options. Under Arne Slot, Liverpool have reshaped their squad identity and tactical balance, winning the Premier League in his first season at the club in 2024/25, but Slot has publicly distanced the club from speculation over Elliott’s situation.

Before the Wolves fixture, Slot said, “No, Harvey is an Aston Villa player,” and suggested questions should be directed elsewhere. Joyce’s update supports Slot’s position that Liverpool cannot influence proceedings, but it does little to soften supporter concerns over wasted potential, stalled minutes, and strategic uncertainty.