3 Positives and 3 Negatives to take from Newcastle 1 Southampton 0

In partnership with

The Mag

·18 August 2024

3 Positives and 3 Negatives to take from Newcastle 1 Southampton 0

Saturday afternoon’s match ended Newcastle 1 Southampton 0.

Ahead of each match we ask one of our writers to come up with three positives and three negatives following the game.

OneFootball Videos

Plenty to talk about after this one…

On this occasion it is ‘Matt Busby said to Joe Harvey…’:

POSITIVES

We got over the line

Down to ten men with two thirds of the game left, we showed resilience and fortitude to emerge victorious.

Okay, I didn’t imagine winning against newly promoted Southampton would be such hard work and be so much relief when the final whistle blew, but we edged it in the end, and can still boast a 100 percent record in the league after our opening fixture.

Strength in depth

Whilst much has been made of our lack of activity in the transfer market this summer, we had options off the bench to both reshuffle when Schar went off and then, introduce much needed reinforcements as the game wore on.

Contrast that with last season when at times we were so threadbare that there were no viable options off the bench and we lost games in the dying embers.

Nick Pope, in the middle of our goal

There were lots of heroes out there today, Joelinton was a colossus and won us the game, Bruno covered every blade of grass, Isak was so alert in assisting big Joe and the defence was resolute, even accounting for young Lewis Hall being under par, his goalline clearance was immense.

However, make no mistake, without Nick Pope today, we wouldn’t have won.

His presence calms the back four and the rest of the team, he made a big save from Armstrong at a crucial time and up in the stands, you just feel assured knowing it’s Nick that’s between the sticks.

NEGATIVES

A suspension already!

Fabian Schar should count his blessings that his teammates got us over the line.

Whilst there’s little doubting Brereton Diaz provoked the Swiss, simulated and then conned the referee, Schar has to accept that putting your forehead anywhere near that of an opponent runs the risk of a red card and his actions could have cost us the game. He’s also going to miss Bournemouth and Spurs.

A shaky performance?

The game turned dramatically in the 28th minute when Schar received his marching orders, but up to that point, we were hardly convincing and even with ten men, I wonder whether other genuine top four contenders would have allowed their opponent to dominate possession and not get at a quite dreadful Southampton side?

VAR is back, or rather it isn’t!

I think there is little doubt Brereton Diaz cheated. He was a disgrace and whilst Fabian Schar was always running the risk of a red card by acting the way he did, you have to wonder why VAR didn’t intervene?

We’ve heard so much about how it’s going to be better, how much improved it’ll be this season and yet, this was a huge opportunity for VAR to demonstrate its positive credentials and get it right.

For me, the incident could have seen both teams reduced to ten men or alternatively, an instruction given to Pawson to knock some sense into Diaz and Schar. As for Pawson’s performance, I’ll leave it there…

Stats via BBC Sport:

Newcastle 1 Southampton 0 – Saturday 17 August 3pm

Goals:

Newcastle United:

Schar red card 28, Joelinton 45

Southampton:

(Half-time stats in brackets)

Possession was Newcastle 22% (27%) Southampton 78% (73%)

Total shots were Newcastle 3 (3) Southampton 19 (4)

Shots on target were Newcastle 1 (1) Southampton 5 (1)

Corners were Newcastle 3 (3) Southampton 12 (1)

Touches in the box Newcastle 16 (11) Southampton 48 (8)