Atlanta United's Jamal Thiaré: super sub or starting striker? | OneFootball

After scoring in consecutive games as a second-half substitute, Jamal Thiaré may be forcing Atlanta United into a pivotal decision.

Thiaré has showcased moments of brilliance -- including the matchwinner in Wednesday's 3-2 win over Orlando City -- and scored three goals in just 282 total minutes. And with Emmanuel Latte Lath in a nine-match goalscoring drought, the question is whether Thiaré's impact is maximized as a starting striker or as a dynamic substitute.

Thiaré's 2025 season has been marked by remarkable efficiency. He ranks second on the team in goals scored, trailing only Latte Lath by two despite playing considerably fewer minutes. His non-penalty goals per 90 minutes placed him seventh in MLS, and he ranks 12th in non-penalty expected goals (xG), ninth in post-shot xG, and fifth in xG per shot, highlighting his ability to create and capitalize on high-quality scoring opportunities.

And Thiaré's knack for delivering in crucial moments cannot be overstated. In a match against Toronto FC last June, he scored a dramatic 97th-minute winner by cleverly dispossessing the goalkeeper and slotting the ball into an empty net. Earlier that season, Thiaré made a significant impact by scoring a brace in a 3-0 win over Chicago Fire, marking his first MLS goal and earning him a spot on the MLS Team of the Matchday.

Then came his biggest moment of all, scoring a brace in the club's 3-2 victory over Inter Miami CF in Game 3 of Round One, arguably his most impactful appearance as a starter.

But there is still considerable doubt over whether Thiaré would be as effective if Ronny Deila put him back in his starting XI, or if he's at his best when the game is at its most open. Let's take a look at both possibilities.

The benefitsof making Thiaré a starter

Potential high ceiling

Thiaré's impressive goals-per-90-minutes ratio speaks for itself. And if he could come anywhere close to it as a starter, he'd be one of MLS' best strikers.

Building attacking chemistry

Starting could allow Thiaré to develop on-field relationships, enhancing team cohesion and attacking fluidity as the misfiring Latte Lath's goal drought continues.

Keeping him engaged

While Thiaré has been excellent off the bench, only a few players are satisfied in that role. Starting him if his numbers deserve it may help keep him bought in.

The potential of Thiaré the super sub

Exploiting Tired Defenses

Introducing Thiaré in the latter stages allows him to leverage his pace, power and agility against fatigued opponents.

Game-Changing Potential

His track record of scoring decisive goals late in matches highlights his effectiveness in this role.

Injury Management

Limiting his minutes can help mitigate the risk of injuries, ensuring his availability throughout the season.

Fan perspectives and club decisions

The Atlanta United fan base has expressed mixed feelings about Thiaré's role. Some appreciate his contributions as a reliable backup, while others advocate for a more prominent starting position. The club's decision to re-sign him for the 2025 season, with an option for 2026, indicates their recognition of his value.

Determining Thiaré's optimal role requires a nuanced approach that considers his health, the team's tactical needs, and match-specific scenarios. While his efficiency suggests he could thrive as a starter, his proven impact as a substitute offers strategic advantages.

A hybrid approach, where Thiaré starts in specific matches and serves as a super sub in others, might provide the best balance, maximizing his contributions while managing his physical demands. As Atlanta United continues its campaign, the flexibility in deploying Thiaré could be a pivotal factor in achieving sustained success.