Coluna do Fla
·9 October 2025
CBF shares VAR audio: Abel’s shocking penalty explanation

In partnership with
Yahoo sportsColuna do Fla
·9 October 2025
After the 3-2 defeat to Palmeiras, São Paulo requested the CBF to release the VAR audio regarding the clear penalty not awarded to the team. The incident, which sparked a strong reaction from fans and commentators, occurred in the second half of the match played at Morumbis.
This Thursday (09), the CBF released the conversation between the refereeing team. Referee Ramon Abatti Abel stated: "Slipped. The ball is passing. Can continue."
Subsequently, VAR Ilbert Estevam da Silva reinforced the decision: "That's exactly it. He slips, the contact is accidental and the ball is leaving the area."
The incident mentioned above involved Allan and Gonzalo Tapia, in a play within the Palmeiras area. At the time, São Paulo was leading 2-0. The referees ignored the possible penalty, even with visible contact.
The play occurred seven minutes into the second half. Ilbert Estevam da Silva, responsible for the VAR, did not recommend a review. The decision sparked outrage among fans, directors, and commentators.
In addition, in the first half, Gustavo Gómez stepped on Tapia during a ball dispute. The incident went without VAR review. In the final stage, the two were involved in another play, where the São Paulo player left with a bleeding nose.
Shortly after, at ten minutes, Andreas Pereira hit Marcos Antônio's ankle in a hard tackle in midfield. The referee only showed the yellow card.
The result at Morumbis directly impacted the fight for the lead in the Brasileirão. With the victory, Palmeiras reached 50 points and matched Flamengo's score on the table.
However, the Rubro-Negro lost the first position for having fewer victories than the green team. In other words, Flamengo was indirectly affected after the classic between São Paulo and Palmeiras.
This article was translated into English by Artificial Intelligence. You can read the original version in 🇧🇷 here.