Everton Back Dyche Despite Poor Form as Ownership Saga Continues | OneFootball

Sean Dyche’s Future at Everton Hangs in the Balance Despite Backing from Hierarchy

Everton find themselves at a familiar yet unenviable crossroads. Sean Dyche, tasked with steering the ship through turbulent Premier League waters, is once again under the microscope after a disastrous start to the season. Following three consecutive defeats and a raft of disappointed fans at Goodison Park, questions are mounting about the manager’s long-term prospects. However, in the face of adversity, Dyche retains support from the Everton hierarchy. According to Chris Bascombe of The Telegraph, the boardroom remains aligned in backing their manager, at least for the remainder of the season.

Sean Dyche’s Dilemma

Sean Dyche’s stint as Everton boss has been characterised by firefighting. Since replacing Frank Lampard in January 2023, he has done what was required of him: keeping Everton in the Premier League. With the financial burden weighing heavily on the club and players such as Anthony Gordon and Amadou Onana offloaded to balance the books, Dyche has managed to maintain stability. However, this season, Everton’s poor form has left them rooted to the bottom of the table.

Bascombe paints a concerning picture. Despite “delivering Premier League safety amid ever-increasing financial restraints,” Dyche faces a critical juncture. The patience of supporters is wearing thin, and there are whispers that any future takeover by prospective owners like John Textor could put Dyche’s position under further scrutiny.

Photo: IMAGO

Tensions on the Pitch and in the Stands

Perhaps the most damaging aspect of this situation is the disconnect between Dyche and sections of the Everton fanbase. The club’s struggles at home have resulted in a chorus of boos from the Goodison Park faithful, especially after losses to Brighton and Bournemouth. Everton’s recent collapse against Bournemouth, where they threw away a 2-0 lead to lose 3-2, has only worsened the mood.

As Bascombe reports, Dyche’s employers feel much of this criticism is “unfair,” especially considering the challenging circumstances under which he has had to operate. They argue that his achievements, such as maintaining Premier League status, deserve more recognition than the backlash he’s received. But football is a results-driven business, and supporters’ frustrations won’t subside without an immediate turnaround.

Everton’s Financial Struggles Continue to Loom Large

Another layer of complexity in this saga is Everton’s ongoing financial issues. Cost-cutting measures have been a hallmark of the club’s strategy over the last two seasons, with the wage bill significantly reduced. Yet, the spectre of potential penalties from previous overspending hangs over the club, further complicating the situation. Bascombe notes that the club is confident they are in no immediate danger of further sanctions, but financial uncertainty lingers, much like Dyche’s tenure.

Moreover, while Everton did manage to hold onto key players such as Jarrad Branthwaite, who attracted attention from Manchester United, injuries have prevented the centre-back from featuring so far this season. This highlights another issue for Dyche: he simply hasn’t had the luxury of working with a fully fit squad.

Ownership Uncertainty Clouds Long-Term Decisions

Perhaps the biggest factor influencing Dyche’s future is the ongoing uncertainty surrounding Everton’s ownership. With Farhad Moshiri seemingly looking to sell the club, any long-term decisions regarding Dyche’s contract have been put on hold. As Bascombe reports, “If a deal is struck between Moshiri and a buyer, they will have to defer to the next owner’s view on who should manage the side.”

In the interim, Dyche must focus on securing the points necessary to climb out of the drop zone. Whether or not he has the time to convince the fans and prospective owners remains to be seen. But one thing is clear: the pressure is mounting.

Our View – EPL Index Analysis

Everton fans have every reason to feel disillusioned. Despite Sean Dyche’s best efforts, the club has seen little tangible progress. While some may argue that Dyche deserves more time given the financial constraints, it’s difficult for supporters to ignore the current results. Losing at home to Brighton and Bournemouth is simply unacceptable for a club of Everton’s stature.

The prospect of new ownership also casts a shadow over any real assessment of Dyche’s tenure. How can fans buy into his long-term vision if the next owner may have an entirely different strategy? Evertonians crave stability, but it’s hard to see where that stability will come from if the ownership saga drags on.

For now, Dyche has the backing of the board, but the lack of trust among the fanbase is glaring. “If Dyche was German he would be working within the Red Bull empire,” according to one Everton director, but the fans aren’t buying that logic. They see a side at the bottom of the table, and the frustration is palpable.

In summary, Dyche might survive the season, but without an upturn in results and clarity on the ownership front, his long-term future at Everton looks anything but secure.