Everton Face Two Issues In This 29-Year-Old Striker’s Chase: Will He Be The Right Solution For The Toffees? | OneFootball

Everton and Tottenham Hotspur will enter the winter window with similar intentions, according to journalist Harry Watkinson. Both clubs appear eager to strengthen their front lines, and interest in Ivan Toney has surfaced after the striker’s standout run with Al-Ahli this season.

Although the 29-year-old left Brentford last year in a move that surprised many, he quickly adapted and produced consistent performances. Since the start of the 2025/26 campaign, his tally of 11 goals and two assists across 17 matches has demonstrated his effectiveness inside the box and reminded everyone of his Premier League pedigree.

Everton face two issues in the chase for Ivan Toney

However, problems remain, as his current weekly wage of £400,000 presents a major obstacle, and if he departs halfway through the season, it may impact his hopes of securing a spot in England’s squad for the 2026 World Cup.

JEDDAH, SAUDI ARABIA – SEPTEMBER 19: Ivan Toney of Al Ahli celebrates scoring his team’s second goal during the Saudi Pro League match between Al Ahli and Al Hilal at King Abdullah Sports City on September 19, 2025 in Jeddah, Saudi Arabia. (Photo by Yasser Bakhsh/Getty Images)

That concern alone could make a move unlikely, even if both clubs are still open to exploring a deal. Everton’s lack of clinical finishing this term, along with Tottenham’s need for depth, means they will keep monitoring the situation, but persuading Al-Ahli and the player may require significant concessions.

Will Toney be the solution to the Beto crisis?

Looking at Everton’s squad issues, recent displays from Beto have shown positive signs without offering lasting confidence. By contrast, Toney has shown more effective instincts in the box, better off-the-ball movement, and a more direct mindset in front of goal. While every striker goes through slow spells, his current form suggests he inspires more trust in tight matches, especially when chances are limited.

Beto’s habit of hesitating at crucial moments has cost points, whereas Toney’s calmness often decides games. On top of that, the 29-year-old’s experience in high-pressure situations could provide useful leadership to a squad still chasing stability. Even though wages and timing might make any transfer difficult, if we look purely at his potential impact on the pitch, it will strengthen the argument. If Everton want a forward who stays alert regardless of how the game flows, the 29-year-old looks capable of bringing better results than what their current forward has produced this season.