Experts hit back at Hummels: criticism of Dortmund sparks debate | OneFootball

Borussia Dortmund receives backing from experts following Mats Hummels' sharp criticism. Several former professionals view BVB's development much more positively than the former defensive leader.

Mats Hummels’ strong criticism of Dortmund’s midfield has sparked a widespread debate—and is now prompting clear counterarguments from several experts. The former defensive chief, speaking as a Prime Video pundit, complained that the composition of the midfield was “a bit diffuse,” as “very different types of players” were being used there. The regular rotation led to new patterns of play, which Hummels described by saying: “With the changes and rotation, you get different types of players who offer themselves differently.”

Former BVB pro Steffen Freund considers this assessment too negative. Speaking to RTL/ntv and sport.de, he pointed out that the team has clearly developed under coaches like Marco Rose, Thomas Tuchel, and most recently Nuri Sahin, and he explicitly disagreed with Hummels: “The overall development at Borussia Dortmund is definitely positive.”

Freund also explained Hummels’ harsh words by referencing his still-young status as an expert: “That’s of course completely normal and human; I did the same after I stopped playing for Dortmund.” And he sent a clear message to the ex-defender: “So Mats, don’t think too much like Borussia Dortmund now, but as an expert.”

Criticism of BVB: Hamann and Freund Disagree with Hummels

Freund also pointed out that there have recently been some demanding opponents. For example, BVB played “very, very close” against VfB Stuttgart and, despite a spectacular duel, only managed a draw. At the same time, the 4-0 win over Villarreal in the Champions League was an important signal, especially as a place among the top eight now seems realistic—a benefit that could ease Dortmund’s burden in the second half of the season.

Dietmar Hamann also clearly disagreed with Hummels. For the Sky expert, the criticism regarding the number of midfielders makes little sense: “They have four or five options in the center and no matter who plays, it works.” He also emphasized that a team with Dortmund’s ambitions cannot go through the season with a rigid starting eleven: “You can’t play 45 or 50 games with the same formation.”

BVB coach Niko Kovac can choose in midfield between Felix Nmecha, Marcel Sabitzer, Jobe Bellingham, Pascal Groß, Carney Chukwuemeka, and Emre Can.

This article was translated into English by Artificial Intelligence. You can read the original version in 🇩🇪 here.