Anfield Index
·10 May 2026
Former Liverpool star claims Arne Slot has to go

In partnership with
Yahoo sportsAnfield Index
·10 May 2026

Liverpool’s season has drifted into dangerous waters and now former winger Jermaine Pennant has delivered the sort of public criticism that cuts through the noise around the club. Following the Reds’ frustrating 1-1 draw with Chelsea, Pennant launched a fierce attack on Arne Slot and questioned whether the Dutchman should remain in charge beyond the summer.
The original source of the story emerged from CaughtOffside, where Pennant’s comments reflected a growing sense of frustration among supporters after another underwhelming display. Liverpool have slipped alarmingly from the standards expected at the club, with defensive fragility and inconsistent performances becoming recurring themes under Slot.
Pennant did not attempt to soften his opinion. Posting on X after the match, the former Liverpool player said:
“Enough of the excuses now, yes injuries don’t help but every team has injuries, but this is enough now, Slot can not be the manager next season, cos this style of football is not Liverpool. Don’t tell me he won the league last season, he’s got to go end of.”
Those words will resonate loudly because they tap into a wider anxiety around the direction of the side. Liverpool supporters have long accepted transitional periods when there is evidence of progress, but recent performances have instead raised doubts over identity, intensity and leadership.

Copyright: imago/Contrast
Pressure on Slot has intensified over recent weeks and the atmosphere at Anfield during the Chelsea draw suggested patience is wearing thin. The decision to substitute Rio Ngumoha drew audible frustration from sections of the crowd, underlining how tense the relationship between manager and supporters has become.
Results have not helped. Liverpool’s record this season has fallen well below expectations, with too many dropped points against sides they would once have overwhelmed. The defensive numbers tell a concerning story and the side has often looked uncertain both in and out of possession.
There is also a growing sense that Liverpool’s football has lost its edge. Under previous successful eras, the club carried a feeling of relentlessness. Opponents knew what was coming. At present, Liverpool often appear passive, lacking the aggression and clarity that once defined them.
Pennant’s criticism may sound brutal, but it reflects the unforgiving standards attached to the role. Liverpool managers are judged not only on results but on style, authority and emotional connection with the supporters. Right now, Slot is struggling on all three fronts.
The draw against Chelsea exposed familiar flaws. Liverpool controlled spells of possession but rarely looked convincing when the game demanded authority. Chelsea found space too easily in transition and Liverpool’s defensive organisation once again appeared vulnerable under pressure.
While injuries have undeniably disrupted the campaign, Pennant’s argument is that injuries alone cannot explain the decline. Elite clubs are expected to cope with setbacks. Squad depth, adaptability and mentality become decisive factors over a long season.
Slot has defended his players repeatedly in recent months and insisted Liverpool remain capable of recovering their form, but the mood around the club has shifted sharply. Supporters are no longer discussing title ambitions or tactical evolution. Instead, conversations increasingly centre on whether Slot is the right figure to lead the next chapter.
That represents a dramatic change in tone considering the optimism that surrounded him after last season’s title success. Football moves quickly, particularly at clubs where expectation never fades.
Liverpool’s hierarchy now face a defining period. Removing a manager only a year after major success would once have seemed unthinkable, yet modern football rarely allows sentiment to outweigh momentum.
There remains time for Slot to steady the situation, but the margin for error has narrowed considerably. Results, performances and atmosphere all point towards a club losing confidence in its direction. If Liverpool limp towards the finish line without improvement, serious discussions about the managerial position will become unavoidable.
Pennant’s outburst may divide opinion, but it has added another layer to an already volatile situation. What matters now is whether Slot can restore belief quickly enough to silence the growing criticism surrounding him.
For Liverpool, the coming weeks feel significant not just for league position, but for the future shape of the club itself.







































