Limp loss to Sunderland feels like Groundhog Day for Moyes and Everton | OneFootball

(Photo by Matt McNulty/Getty Images)

The most depressing part about the all-but-official end of Everton’s European hopes was that it was almost entirely predictable. As Sunderland slammed the final nail in the continental competition coffin, it was hard not to feel like this was Groundhog Day.

​Everton had failed to win in five before the final home fixture of the campaign, but the team sheet told a different story.

​Unchanged for the third straight game, David Moyes again placed his trust in a team that had squandered leads against Manchester City and Crystal Palace. Hindsight is wonderful, but as Everton again gave up a lead, was anyone truly surprised? What’s the definition of insanity, again?

​Everton’s opener had been a stroke of good fortune. Merlin Rohl, one of the few to recently disrupt the ‘settled’ side Moyes has preferred this season, opened his account with the help of a wicked deflection.

A half-time lead, and with Brentford losing, the Blues were, briefly, in the European places. How it unravelled.

​The build-up to Sunderland’s equaliser perhaps summarised Everton across the run-in, and for much of the campaign. A brilliant breakaway broke down as Iliman Ndiaye’s slack pass was cut out, with the visitors charging down the other end to level. Jake O’Brien’s loose touch was pounced upon, and Brian Brobbey bullied James Tarkowski on route to goal. Everton’s failings in both boxes once more on show, a microcosm of the campaign.

​Sunderland’s second stunned Hill Dickinson, but it was no less than they deserved. The visitors were more composed, more committed to winning a game that was there to be won. Enzo Le Fee soaked in the celebrations, while Jordan Pickford will not want to watch it back. Unsighted, perhaps, but a weak hand nonetheless.

​Moyes’s management continued the predictability theme. Beto brought off for Barry. 73 minutes on the clock. It didn’t need a crystal ball to see what was coming. Beto has started 17 games in the Premier League this season and has been substituted in the window between 64 and 81 minutes in 14 of them. Groundhog Day.

​Tyrique George, introduced alongside him, offered something Barry did not. A lively cameo included a fizzed cross that O’Brien somehow headed straight at Robin Roefs. After one start and less than 200 minutes of Premier League football, George must be wondering whether he’d have been better served sticking around at Chelsea.

​Sunderland’s stoppage-time third summarised an afternoon few will want to revisit, a collaborative defensive disaster class. Vitallii Mykolenko tracked Habib Diarra’s run with an inexcusable lack of urgency, before Michael Keane and Seamus Coleman gave the ‘corridor of uncertainty’ a whole new meaning. Wilson Isidor gratefully accepted the gift.

​And there, up in smoke, went Everton’s European dream. A wretched run-in has undone what had been a promising position, in a season where a place in Europe was there to be taken. The Finch Farm mirrors need to receive some long looks over the summer.

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer ()

Moyes has got to take a long hard look at himself. He's not getting the best out of these players. That falls on the manager. I've always been a big Moyes fan but you can't finish a season like this and get away with it. Can't even blame it on injuries either. Nearly had a fully fit squad. We're on course to finish exactly where we finished last season if you look at the other clubs fixtures (we won't beat Spurs in this form). The recruitment's been poor yet again if you look at the overall picture. It's unacceptable. Now I would honestly go all out for Iraola.

After watching that first half of the Wedt Ham game I hope to fuck that Moyes doesn't make Soucek our marquee signing of the summer, he's slow and looks completely out of his depth, but he a typical Davey Moyes player so I wouldn't be surprised to see him with a scarf and a 3 year contract next summer, smiling his head off telling us how wonderful Dour Davey is

Ajay Gopal 3 Posted 17/05/2026 at 18:39:03

Along with Moyes, Kinnear also needs to go. Make Tim Cahill as the CEO and get any of Glasner, Iraola, Howe or Maresca as the manager. Get Kevin Thelwell back as Footballing Director, his recruitment was far better than Kinnear’s team. I wish Everton had waited until the end of season to extend Keane and Tarkoski’s contracts.

Sell off Tarkowski, Keane, McNeil, Ndiaye, Patterson, Barry. I wouldn’t make Grealish’s loan permanent. Get in 2 centre-backs, 1 right back, 1 striker and 1 winger. And with a good manager we might be competing in the top half of the table.