Newcastle United Unwilling To Pay €45 Million To Sign This Brazilian Midfielder: Is It The Right Decision? | OneFootball

According to ESPN, Allan Elias carries a price tag close to €45 million; therefore, Newcastle United have responded cautiously, as the Magpies currently refuse to stretch that far despite a clear need for added quality and depth through the centre of midfield.

However, that hesitation does not remove the bigger picture, since Newcastle have reached a point where small improvements carry extra weight, especially after recent progress that pushed the club back into the UEFA Champions League while also delivering a long-awaited domestic trophy, and that momentum calls for smart reinforcement rather than reckless spending. As a result, recruitment chiefs continue to assess value closely, knowing that every major fee needs to bring control, consistency, and resilience across a long season.

Newcastle United have responded cautiously to €45 million-rated Allan Elias

Meanwhile, Newcastle keep Allan Elias firmly on their radar, largely because his profile matches what Eddie Howe looks for, as he brings energy, press-resistance, and tactical discipline, while also showing room to develop across multiple roles in the middle of the pitch. Moreover, the Magpies have struggled for balance at times this season, and those uneven performances often stem from midfield gaps that expose the defence or isolate the attack.

NEWCASTLE UPON TYNE, ENGLAND – DECEMBER 06: Eddie Howe, Manager of Newcastle United, looks on prior to the Premier League match between Newcastle United and Burnley at St James’ Park on December 06, 2025 in Newcastle upon Tyne, England. (Photo by George Wood/Getty Images)

At the same time, the Brazilian midfielder reportedly likes the idea of a Premier League move because Newcastle can offer regular minutes, European nights, and a platform that helps young players improve their game against elite opposition. Consequently, he may push internally for flexibility if talks progress, although his club understands their leverage and sees no urgency to compromise early.

Should the Magpies pay that amount for him?

Still, despite their wealth, the Tyneside outfit continues to set firm limits, since they prefer negotiation over impulse, and they want a fee that reflects genuine promise rather than pure potential. That approach aligns with a wider plan focused on sustainability, especially as the Champions League demands test squad depth across all fronts.

Looking ahead, January could determine the direction of the season, because Newcastle need midfield reinforcement to improve their performances and maintain league momentum, yet they must avoid deals that disrupt long-term planning. In our view, Allan Elias fits Newcastle’s needs and direction, and he could develop into a strong Premier League midfielder, although only at the right price, since paying €45 million now feels premature rather than necessary.