OffsAIde
·20 September 2026
Phil Smith's Sunderland AFC player ratings v Man City with perfect 10 and one nine despite defeat

In partnership with
Yahoo sportsOffsAIde
·20 September 2026

Sunderland lost 5-3 to Man City in a remarkable Premier League contest at the Etihad Stadium, despite Brian Brobbeys hat-trick and a flurry of chances.
Sunderland Echo reports Phil Smiths player ratings from the afternoon at the Etihad.
Robin Roefs was caught too far across his line for the opener from a near-post free-kick, with little he could do about the rest, rated five.
Nordi Mukiele impressed before the interval, largely containing his flank, then dipped after the break with a few loose passes before finishing strongly, given six.
Dan Ballard stood up well in duels and, despite the scoreline, produced a broadly strong display, though a couple of overeager challenges cost ground, awarded seven.
Kevin Danso contributed plenty defensively, yet a misplaced pass out invited Citys second, then in the second half a clearance ricocheted off a team-mate to an opponent, marked five.
Source: Sunderland Echo
“Artificial intelligence was used to assist in creating this article based on reporting from the original source quoted.”


Live


Live


Live


Live































