Phil Smith's Sunderland AFC player ratings v Man City with perfect 10 and one nine despite defeat | OneFootball

Phil Smith's Sunderland AFC player ratings v Man City with perfect 10 and one nine despite defeat | OneFootball

In partnership with

Yahoo sports
Icon: OffsAIde

OffsAIde

·20 September 2026

Phil Smith's Sunderland AFC player ratings v Man City with perfect 10 and one nine despite defeat

Article image:Phil Smith's Sunderland AFC player ratings v Man City with perfect 10 and one nine despite defeat

Sunderland lost 5-3 to Man City in a remarkable Premier League contest at the Etihad Stadium, despite Brian Brobbeys hat-trick and a flurry of chances.

Sunderland Echo reports Phil Smiths player ratings from the afternoon at the Etihad.


OneFootball Videos


Robin Roefs was caught too far across his line for the opener from a near-post free-kick, with little he could do about the rest, rated five.

Nordi Mukiele impressed before the interval, largely containing his flank, then dipped after the break with a few loose passes before finishing strongly, given six.

Dan Ballard stood up well in duels and, despite the scoreline, produced a broadly strong display, though a couple of overeager challenges cost ground, awarded seven.

Kevin Danso contributed plenty defensively, yet a misplaced pass out invited Citys second, then in the second half a clearance ricocheted off a team-mate to an opponent, marked five.

“Artificial intelligence was used to assist in creating this article based on reporting from the original source quoted.”

View publisher imprint