Report: 12 clubs are in the race to sign Man United star in January | OneFootball

Mainoo’s Stalled Momentum Raises Serious Questions

Manchester United once took pride in fast tracking homegrown excellence. Kobbie Mainoo symbolised that promise, a midfielder of calm authority, balance, and maturity far beyond his years. Yet the latest developments reveal a player stuck in a holding pattern, watching opportunities drift past while frustration builds around him.

Thursday’s 1-1 draw with West Ham only sharpened the debate. Mainoo remained seated as United searched for a winning goal, and when the change came it was defender Lisandro Martinez who stepped onto the pitch. For a talent who starts for England, this was a symbolic moment, one that has amplified external noise and internal uncertainty.

Photo IMAGO

Paul Scholes certainly did not hold back. His comments cut sharply through the club’s messaging, accusing Ruben Amorim of mishandling a rising star. Scholes called the suggestion that Mainoo is a starter “bull***”* and went further with a damning addition. “The kid is being ruined, not being played in a team that can’t control a game of football. Hate seeing homegrown players leave but it’s probably best for him now, enough is enough.”

Growing Demand Across Europe

Daily Mail’s reporting revealed that interest in Mainoo is immense, with at least twelve clubs ready to take him on loan in January. Napoli tried in the summer and remain keen, while sides in England, Italy, Spain and Germany have already made their intentions clear.

In truth, the situation reflects a wider concern. When a player with Mainoo’s profile accumulates only 171 Premier League minutes in nine substitute appearances, something is misaligned. A Carabao Cup start in defeat at Grimsby feels a faint reward for a midfielder expected to play a central role in England’s long term plans.

United’s Stance and Amorim’s Defence

Amorim is steadfast. He insists he will not be pressured into selection decisions. “Of course, I understand,” he said. “My job is to answer, but I am trying to answer always the same thing, and you ask me always the same thing.”

He expanded further. “I understand what you are saying. You love Kobbie. He starts for England, but that doesn’t mean I need to put in Kobbie when I feel I shouldn’t put in Kobbie.”

Amorim maintains that training standards dictate selection and that Mainoo is competing directly with Bruno Fernandes, alongside Casemiro and Manuel Ugarte. Asked about the player’s unhappiness, he replied bluntly. “I see it. I see it and I just want to win. I just put in the players, I don’t look who it is, I don’t care about that, I just try to put the best players on the pitch.”

What Comes Next

Mainoo wants minutes to strengthen his England case ahead of the World Cup. United want authority and control in midfield. Amorim wants results. Something has to give, and January may provide the only workable release valve. The real danger for United is allowing another academy jewel to drift towards the exit with his potential untapped on their watch.

Our View, EPL Index Analysis

Supporters across the league will feel a mix of shock and disappointment reading this situation unfold. A player who looked destined to anchor United for years is now searching for playing time like an overlooked squad option. Fans will struggle to understand how an England starter can sit out a crucial moment in a 1-1 draw, especially when United needed control and creativity in midfield.

There is also a growing expectation that a loan move might be the best solution. Many supporters will argue that Mainoo deserves somewhere that values his progression rather than stalling it. Napoli and others offer real opportunities, and the idea of him flourishing abroad is beginning to feel more exciting than worrying.

At the same time, some fans will sympathise with Amorim’s stance. Managers live by results and short term decisions often override long term ideals. Still, the optics are brutal. When legends like Scholes speak out so strongly, it fuels scepticism and anxiety. More than anything, supporters simply want clarity and a plan that protects one of England’s brightest midfielders.

If United cannot provide that, others definitely will.