Report: Arsenal eyeing surprise move to sign former Man United star | OneFootball

Arsenal and Man Utd Assess Midfield Gamble as Napoli Stand Firm

Rising Influence in Italy

Scott McTominay’s Serie A adventure has become one of the most intriguing late-career reinventions of recent years. Once pigeonholed in England as an industrious presence who relied on graft more than guile, the midfielder has embraced a fresh identity in Naples. TeamTalk’s report highlights how his “eight goals and four assists already this season” underpin his importance to Antonio Conte’s structure, and it is easy to understand why interest from England’s elite is intensifying.

Photo IMAGO

The midfield role McTominay now occupies has demanded constant pressure, intelligent movement and decisive contributions in both penalty areas. His consistency has helped drive Napoli’s title bid, with his displays described by insiders as central to capturing Serie A’s momentum. As one Napoli source noted, “We’re building something special here, Scott’s thriving, why would they disrupt that?”

Transfer Stakes Rising

Interest from Arsenal, Man Utd, Tottenham Hotspur and Everton reflects both the player’s growing stature and the Premier League’s appetite for proven, athletic midfielders who can endure the pace of English football. TeamTalk’s claim that “Scott’s heart still beats for the Premier League” reveals a personal tug that has not fully faded.

But romance does not outweigh the financial reality. Napoli, reinforced by his transformation, are demanding an “astronomical” sum to even open a conversation. The suggestion that any offer below €80m would be dismissed illustrates the new valuation of a player once considered a squad figure in Manchester. Napoli’s stance makes sense, given his impact within Conte’s 3-5-2 and the scarcity of midfield options who can match his mix of physicality and smart timing.

Premier League Options Under Review

Arsenal’s interest reflects broader squad-building goals. Their midfield has required greater depth, particularly in performances where late runs from deep could change tight matches. McTominay’s evolution into a goal threat in high-pressure phases suits that requirement. Man Utd’s name in the mix adds a layer of intrigue, given the player’s departure in search of greater scope to grow, though the idea of a nostalgic return feels less realistic under current leadership.

Photo IMAGO

Tottenham’s admiration, first linked in late October, also aligns with their need for robust midfield profiles. Meanwhile, Everton’s approach to his camp, as confirmed by TeamTalk, shows ambition but lacks the financial muscle at this stage for any record-breaking offer.

Long Road to Any Agreement

For now, the midfielder remains committed to Napoli’s Champions League trajectory. His comments that he is happy in Italy reflect a footballer content in his surroundings, unpressured to force an exit. Premier League clubs, though, rarely let opportunities like this fade without at least testing the water. Whether any of them can match Napoli’s valuation is another matter entirely.

Our View – EPL Index Analysis

Arsenal fans have long appreciated players who combine discipline with timing, and McTominay’s improvement in Italy would not be dismissed lightly. His knack for arriving late in the box would add something the current squad occasionally lacks, particularly in cagey matches where creativity alone does not break resistance.

However, questions naturally emerge. Would his success in Serie A seamlessly translate back to the Premier League? Arsenal supporters have seen players thrive abroad only to struggle with the physical intensity and tactical transitions required in England. There would also be doubts about whether spending upwards of €80m on a 28-year-old fits with the club’s recruitment strategy, which normally leans towards players with strong resale value.

Another factor is identity. Arsenal fans are proud of the technical, positional style developed under their current project. They might worry whether McTominay, even after such a transformation, fully aligns with that approach. Some would argue that Arsenal need a ball-progressing midfielder rather than an energetic disruptor.

Still, there would be a sense of intrigue. If the club genuinely sees him as someone who could elevate their midfield options, supporters would trust the judgement. They have seen players evolve before, and McTominay’s rise in Italy suggests he has more layers than many assumed. Ultimately, while admiration exists, hesitation likely outweighs excitement unless the fee drops or his profile becomes a clearer tactical fit.