Why is changing Arsenal’s captain such a controversial move?

In partnership with

Just Arsenal News

·26 December 2025

Why is changing Arsenal’s captain such a controversial move?

In the summer, there were widespread suggestions that Declan Rice should replace Martin Odegaard as the Arsenal captain, but that proposal was viewed as controversial. While the idea attracted genuine support from sections of the fan base, it was equally clear that many felt the change would not make sense. The divided reaction alone demonstrated why such a decision would inevitably spark debate within the club’s support.

Those in favour of the switch believed there were valid reasons behind it. Leadership roles often invite scrutiny, particularly at clubs with high expectations, and the discussion reflected broader concerns about form, influence, and consistency rather than sentiment alone.

OneFootball Videos

Comparing Performances and Influence

In practical terms, Rice has been the stronger performer for Arsenal over the last few seasons, while Odegaard has endured periods of struggle. Although the Norwegian has shown improvement in recent weeks and remains one of the club’s key players, he has not reached the same level as Rice in terms of impact. Rice has delivered consistently high performances and has often appeared to be the driving force during difficult moments.

Beyond individual displays, Rice’s leadership on the pitch has stood out. He regularly takes responsibility, urging teammates to refocus and raise their intensity when standards drop. During Arsenal’s recent shaky performances, Rice has been the player who most visibly attempted to stabilise the team and demand higher levels from those around him.

(Photo by Shaun Botterill/Getty Images)

Respecting the Final Decision

From that perspective, it is understandable why many believe Rice deserves the Arsenal captaincy, and why some argue that the debate itself should not be particularly controversial. His consistency, authority, and willingness to take ownership align closely with traditional expectations of a captain.

However, leadership structures are not determined by external opinion alone. The players have voted to keep Odegaard as their captain for another season, and that collective decision must be respected. Dressing room unity and trust are essential, and undermining that choice would risk creating unnecessary tension.

While some may continue to feel that Rice represents a more natural captain, the priority now should be supporting the existing leadership. There is hope that Odegaard will continue to improve and grow into the role, ensuring that the decision ultimately benefits both him and the team as a whole.

______________________________________________________________________ ADMIN COMMENT

So here are some simple rules which I must insist commenters follow….

You agree not to give any personal abuse to other Arsenal fans. Everyone is allowed to hold their own opinions even if you disagree with them. It COSTS NOTHING TO BE POLITE TO OTHER ARSENAL FANS.

CALLING ALL ARSENAL FANS! Anyone who would like to contribute an Article or Video opinion piece on JustArsenal, please contact us through this link…