Liverpool warned over Isak price as Garcia questions transfer strategy | OneFootball

Garcia Cautions Liverpool as Isak Price Tag Prompts Transfer Dilemma

Weight of expectation follows Isak pursuit

Liverpool’s summer has carried an edge of urgency and opportunity. The club has long admired Alexander Isak, and their desire to bring him to Anfield has become an open secret. Their £110 million bid, firmly rejected by Newcastle, spoke volumes. But with negotiations paused and the asking price creeping towards £150 million, a different tone has emerged.

Photo IMAGO

One of those raising eyebrows is Luis Garcia. The former Liverpool midfielder, rarely drawn into transfer discourse, has questioned whether such an outlay is justified. “I’m not sure on the price-tag,” Garcia told ESPN. “The development of the player has been incredible. But the price I think is really, really high.”

Attack still potent, but holes remain

There’s a logic to Garcia’s concern that goes beyond mere accounting. “It’s not that you’re a team who needs a centre-forward to score 30, 35 goals,” he added. “You already have a player like that on the right side [Mohamed Salah], and you’ve got a lot of players who can score double figures.”

He is right. Liverpool were not short of goal scorers. Cody Gakpo, Harvey Elliott, and the late Diogo Jota all offered output from wide and central roles. Even with uncertainty around Darwin Nunez, the squad has attacking options.

Photo: IMAGO

What it lacks, perhaps more critically, is defensive security. Joe Gomez remains inconsistent, Ibrahima Konaté’s contract situation is unresolved, and Virgil van Dijk is approaching the twilight of his career.

Centre-back or centre-forward?

Garcia’s view is simple: priorities matter. “I think Isak is a fantastic player and of course he will give you something extra, but I’m not sure spending that money on a striker right now is the best thing for Liverpool.”

Photo IMAGO

It is a sentiment that echoes among sections of the Liverpool support. While Hugo Ekitike’s arrival was seen as promising, he is still viewed as a development project, not an immediate solution. With Nunez’s future unclear, the need for a reliable centre-forward cannot be dismissed.

Yet Garcia’s perspective forces a larger question. Should Liverpool, a club still adapting to life after Jürgen Klopp and navigating an emotionally charged rebuild under Arne Slot, spend record-breaking sums in areas where they already possess depth?

Finding value in a shifting market

Football rarely offers neat answers. Liverpool could, in theory, sign both a top-class striker and a central defender. They have the financial capacity, especially with recent outgoings and Champions League revenue returning.

What Garcia highlights, however, is not financial limitation, but strategic clarity. “You need to make sure you get the right balance,” a source close to the club has said. That balance, right now, may be leaning too heavily toward glamour over grit.

Still, Isak is no ordinary luxury. At 25, with proven Premier League credentials, he could yet be the kind of signing who defines a new era. But only if the rest of the house is in order.