Newcastle United ‘Remain Interested’ in £42m Italian Defender – Report | OneFootball

Newcastle United Keep Tabs on Giorgio Scalvini Amid Injury Uncertainty

Newcastle United’s interest in Giorgio Scalvini refuses to fade, even after the promising Italian centre-back’s recent injury woes. As TeamTalk reported, the Magpies have been tracking the Atalanta defender for over two years, and despite serious injury setbacks, their belief in his potential remains.

At just 21, Scalvini is already an Italy international and a core part of Atalanta’s defensive system when fit. Standing at 6ft4, his ability to operate in a back three or even in midfield makes him a highly adaptable option. Newcastle see him as a high-ceiling investment who, if he overcomes his fitness issues, could become a cornerstone of their backline for years to come.

“Newcastle’s interest remains, with the Premier League side viewing Scalvini as a player who has the potential to become one of the best in his position,” TeamTalk revealed. That is no small claim for a player who made only eight appearances last season due to a serious ACL injury and a follow-up shoulder issue.

Photo: IMAGO

Newcastle’s Defensive Priorities Under Review

Eddie Howe’s side have made steady progress defensively since promotion, but injuries and squad depth continue to pose challenges. With Champions League ambitions firmly in mind, the need for top-level reinforcements is clear.

Still, Newcastle face a dilemma. Scalvini’s contract runs until 2028, giving Atalanta significant negotiating power. Furthermore, his current market valuation of €40-50 million (£34.3m to £42.8m) reflects the high regard in which he is held, even amid his injury setbacks. That kind of fee demands a degree of certainty, particularly in a summer where Financial Fair Play limits are forcing clubs to be more strategic.

“Atalanta… are in no rush to sell prized asset Scalvini,” TeamTalk notes, highlighting how the Serie A club may first offload other stars like Ederson before engaging seriously on Scalvini.

January Window May Provide Clarity

There’s growing belief among suitors that the best time to assess Scalvini’s situation may be in January, when his fitness and form can be judged over a longer period. “Interested parties, including unnamed European clubs, may delay decisions until January to assess Scalvini’s form and fitness post-recovery,” according to sources quoted by TeamTalk.

That timeline could play into Newcastle’s hands. With more time to monitor his recovery and performances, a winter move might make more financial and strategic sense, especially if other defensive options prove inconsistent or are moved on.

If Scalvini shows signs of returning to his best, expect a bidding war. Inter Milan and Juventus remain in the picture, but Newcastle’s long-term scouting and Premier League appeal could tip the scales.

Scalvini’s Fit in Howe’s System

Scalvini’s ball-playing ability, intelligence, and tactical versatility suit Howe’s evolving defensive style. With the Magpies sometimes switching to a back three or using a deep-lying midfielder, Scalvini’s dual capabilities offer rare flexibility.

His maturity and leadership qualities have also been praised by observers in Italy. Eight caps for the Azzurri at his age are no accident. Should he regain fitness, he offers a profile that Newcastle do not currently have in abundance — tall, technical, and comfortable across several defensive roles.

TeamTalk’s report rightly cautions about the risk, but the upside is undeniable. Newcastle must decide whether that gamble is worth taking now or wait to see how Scalvini responds to regular football in the coming months.

Our View – EPL Index Analysis

This is exactly the kind of signing that gets the Toon Army buzzing. Giorgio Scalvini would not just be another squad filler, he’d be a signal of real intent. Young, international pedigree, comfortable on the ball, and built like a classic Premier League defender — this is a player Newcastle fans would absolutely get behind.

Yes, the injury record is a concern, but modern sports science and recovery protocols offer reasons to be optimistic. Look at how players like Callum Wilson and Joelinton have bounced back from setbacks and become key men at St James’ Park.

If Newcastle can structure a deal with performance-related clauses or even a loan with an option to buy in January, it would be a shrewd move. Let’s not forget, these are the types of calculated risks that can pay off huge when chasing top-four finishes.

The competition from Inter and Juve makes it spicy, but Newcastle’s project is building momentum. Scalvini would walk into most Premier League sides, and in black and white, he could become a fan favourite. Fingers crossed his recovery goes smoothly — because this could be a name we hear chanted loud and proud in the Gallowgate soon.