Report: Man United considering move to re-sign former midfielder | OneFootball

Man Utd Consider James Garner Return as Midfield Plans Take Shape

Manchester United are actively exploring options to reshape their midfield, with James Garner emerging as a realistic and financially viable target ahead of the January transfer window. Internal discussions have gathered pace in recent weeks as the club assesses both short-term cover and longer-term succession planning, particularly amid ongoing fitness concerns and contract uncertainty within the squad.

Garner, currently at Everton, is understood to be firmly on United’s radar. Those familiar with the situation indicate that his name has climbed steadily up the shortlist, not as a marquee solution but as a strategic addition who offers familiarity, tactical flexibility and value. Alongside that interest, Elliot Anderson has been identified as the preferred long-term option to anchor the next iteration of United’s midfield.

This is not a sudden pivot, but rather part of a broader recruitment recalibration under the club’s current sporting structure.

Photo: IMAGO

James Garner Situation at Everton

James Garner’s contractual position is central to United’s interest. The midfielder is approaching the final six months of his current deal, though Everton retain a club option that could extend his stay. While the Merseyside club are in talks over a longer contract, there has been no definitive breakthrough, leaving the door ajar for potential suitors.

United’s interest is grounded in pragmatism. Garner is homegrown, tactically schooled in the demands of the Premier League, and well known at Carrington after progressing through the academy. Since leaving Old Trafford, he has developed into a reliable and composed midfielder, capable of operating at the base of midfield or slightly higher when required.

Sources suggest United view Garner as a low-risk acquisition who could contribute immediately while allowing flexibility elsewhere in the squad. Any January move would depend on Everton’s stance and whether contractual clarity can be reached quickly.

Elliot Anderson Priority in Midfield Strategy

While James Garner represents an accessible opportunity, Elliot Anderson is viewed internally as a more ambitious target. Recruitment staff see Anderson as a midfielder capable of shaping United’s next cycle, particularly in terms of intensity, ball-carrying and tactical discipline.

United’s admiration for Anderson predates the current window, and he remains at the top of the midfield wish list. However, any move would likely require significant negotiation and is more plausibly aligned with summer business rather than a mid-season approach.

That distinction is important. United are not looking to solve everything in January. Instead, they are assessing whether elements of the rebuild can be accelerated without compromising long-term planning.

Ruben Amorim Midfield Challenges

Ruben Amorim’s immediate concern is availability. Injuries and workload management have left United stretched, to the point where defensive players have been asked to deputise in midfield roles. While there is trust in younger options, the current situation has underlined the need for reinforcement.

Amorim has publicly acknowledged that January additions remain possible, though departures are unlikely unless replacements are secured first. Internally, there is recognition that even with a full squad, midfield depth is thinner than desired, particularly given the tactical demands placed on central players.

James Garner’s profile fits neatly into that reality. He would not require a lengthy adaptation period and could be deployed across multiple roles, providing immediate cover without altering the wider structure.

January Window Context at Man Utd

Manchester United’s approach to January is shaped by caution rather than urgency. The club is determined to avoid reactive recruitment, instead prioritising deals that align with longer-term objectives and financial sustainability.

Garner’s situation offers that balance. A cut-price deal, should Everton’s negotiations stall, would allow United to strengthen now while reserving greater investment for targets such as Elliot Anderson later in the year.

There is no final decision yet, and much will depend on external movement, including Everton’s contract talks and broader market dynamics. What is clear is that United are laying groundwork rather than scrambling, with James Garner and Elliot Anderson representing two different but complementary strands of the same midfield rebuild.