Rotherham United told to make "sensible" managerial appointment involving 43-year-old | OneFootball

The Chairman’s praise of Hamshaw is co-signed by FLW’s Rotherham United fan pundit

This article is part of Football League World's 'Terrace Talk' series, which provides personal opinions from our FLW Fan Pundits regarding the latest breaking news, teams, players, managers, potential signings and more…

Matt Hamshaw’s immaculate record as interim Rotherham United manager came to an end on Saturday, as the Millers failed to capitalise on a one-goal lead against Stockport County.

An early strike from Sheffield Wednesday loanee Mallik Wilks was not enough to secure points for the visitors, with the Hatters running out 3-1 winners of the tie.

The result, however, cannot discredit Hamshaw’s Rotherham rise. Appointed on the 30th of March immediately following Steve Evans’ sacking, the 43-year old - who had previously served the Millers under Paul Warne - had overseen three consecutive wins since he took charge of the South Yorkshire side.

Millers chairman Tony Stewart has been generous in his praise of the manager, confirming to The Rotherham Advertiser that he hoped Hamshaw would be the right man to appoint for the 2025/26 season, if things went until the end of the season.

Rotherham United told to make "sensible" Matt Hamshaw appointment decision

Football League World spoke with Rotherham United fan pundit Tom Eyre on Matt Hamshaw’s future at the New York Stadium, following Stewart’s comments in the media.

“I think it’d be the most sensible choice to have Matt Hamshaw in charge for the foreseeable,” Eyre told FLW.

“I think he’s proved himself capable in coaching and management certainly with the last three displays he’s definitely shown that, and I think he just shows he’s got a knack for getting it, as a lot of Millers fans say about him at the club.

“I think he’s a manager who completely understands exactly what it means to be a Rotherham United man, and I think it’d be silly not to have him in charge going forward.

“I think it’s something that looks great on paper, and something that can really spearhead the future of the club.

“I would love to second what Tony Stewart said, and appoint Matt Hamshaw in the full-time role.”

Tony Stewart should reward Matt Hamshaw for his turnaround of depleted Rotherham United team

Saturday’s defeat does little to undermine the strong case Matt Hamshaw has made for a permanent appointment.

Inheriting a struggling side low on confidence and fitness, Hamshaw has instilled clarity, purpose, and visible improvement across the pitch.

Three consecutive wins prior to the Stockport result - including a midweek upset against Bolton Wanderers - were not only valuable in the short term but also indicative of a manager with the tactical acumen and leadership required at this level.

His familiarity with the club, shaped by years working under Paul Warne, is complemented by a clear understanding of what Rotherham United demands from its managers - resilience, work ethic, and a commitment to progress.

Crucially, he has already earned the trust of the dressing room and the backing of both fans and senior figures at the club.

As Tony Stewart’s comments suggest, the club is seriously considering continuity beyond the summer. Appointing Hamshaw on a full-time basis for Rotherham would be a logical and forward-thinking decision: one that rewards merit, respects the club’s identity, and offers a stable foundation ahead of the 2025/26 campaign.