Report: Man United want to re-sign former midfielder in major move | OneFootball

Scott McTominay and the Reinvention of a Career in Italy

Scott McTominay’s transformation since leaving Manchester United has been one of the most compelling European stories of the past season. Once a player often framed by utility and compromise, he now stands as Serie A’s Player of the Year, a central pillar in Napoli’s title success and a midfielder reborn. Credit must go to Caught Offside, whose reporting has detailed both the scale of his renaissance and the renewed Premier League interest circling from afar.

Napoli platform unlocks best version

At Napoli, McTominay has found clarity. Under Antonio Conte, his role carries purpose and trust, allowing his athleticism, timing and leadership to flourish. Freed from rigid expectations, he has become a powerful box to box presence, arriving late into the area and influencing matches at decisive moments. As one observer close to the club noted, “This version of McTominay looks like a player who finally knows exactly who he is on the pitch.”

Photo IMAGO

Serie A’s tactical rhythm has played to his strengths. The slightly slower tempo has sharpened his reading of space, while Conte’s structure has protected him defensively. The result has been consistency, authority and goals at moments Napoli needed them most.

Premier League interest reignited

Such progress was always going to travel. Caught Offside report that Manchester United are now “dreaming of bringing the midfielder back home”, a reflection of regret as much as admiration. Tottenham, led by Thomas Frank, see goals and physical presence from midfield as a priority, while Arsenal and Newcastle continue to monitor developments.

Napoli, however, hold the stronger hand. Their valuation of around £60 million underlines McTominay’s importance to Conte’s system and their ambition to push for another Scudetto. January remains unlikely, with insiders suggesting only an extraordinary offer would force movement, though estimates point towards a 70 percent chance of a summer transfer.

Career narrative rewritten

This feels like more than form. McTominay has reshaped the story of his career, trading perception for performance. Whether England calls him back or Italy remains his stage, the midfielder has already achieved something rarer than a transfer saga, genuine reinvention.

Our View – EPL Index Analysis

As supporters watching from England, this report sparks a mix of excitement and unease. There is pride in seeing a Premier League product thrive abroad, but also frustration that it took a move to Italy for his qualities to be fully trusted. For Manchester United fans in particular, this feels like a familiar ache, a player leaving, growing, then suddenly being desired again once he has proven his worth elsewhere.

There is scepticism too. Bringing McTominay back now would mean paying a premium for development that happened outside Old Trafford. That £60 million valuation feels steep, yet justified, and raises uncomfortable questions about planning and patience at elite clubs. Tottenham’s interest feels more logical, a system hungry for power and goals from midfield, while Arsenal viewing him as rotation hints at how far his reputation has travelled.

From a neutral Premier League perspective, there is admiration mixed with concern. Serie A has given McTominay oxygen, time and tactical shelter. Returning him to England risks compressing those spaces again. Fans should be excited by his growth, but wary of assuming that context can be easily recreated. Sometimes, a career’s second act works precisely because it happens somewhere else.