Barnes Gets 9, Ramsdale With 8 | Newcastle United Players Rated In Penalty Shootout Win Vs Bournemouth | OneFootball

Newcastle United welcomed Bournemouth at St. James’ Park earlier tonight as they hoped to earn a good result at home in the FA Cup. The Magpies made a good start to the game but were held to a scoreless draw at the half-time break.

Harvey Barnes scored the opening goal in the 50th minute, which was cancelled out by Alex Scott’s effort just 12 minutes later. David Brooks gave Bournemouth the lead in the 68th minute, but Anthony Gordon equalised for Newcastle in injury time. The match ended 2-2 after full-time and went to extra time.

Anthony Gordon gave Eddie Howe’s side the lead in the 118th minute, but Marcus Tavernier equalised for the Cherries in the dying embers of the contest. The clash finished 3-3 after extra time.

Newcastle ended up winning the tie on penalties after they emerged victorious in the shootout by a 7-6 margin.

Let’s take a look at how each Newcastle United player fared during the clash against the Cherries.

GK: Aaron Ramsdale – 8/10

Ramsdale made a lot of crucial saves at the back, but still ended up conceding three goals today.

RB: Kieran Trippier – 6/10

He was far from convincing when defending inside his half and offered very little going forward.

CB: Malick Thiaw – 7.5/10

Thiaw did his fair share of defending and managed to score his penalty in the shootout.

CB: Sven Botman – 6.5/10

He cleared his lines when he could and was a threat at the other end of the field. However, Botman made a poor error at the back.

NEWCASTLE UPON TYNE, ENGLAND – JANUARY 10: Tino Livramento of Newcastle United is put under pressure by David Brooks of AFC Bournemouth during the Emirates FA Cup Third Round match between Newcastle United and AFC Bournemouth at St James’ Park on January 10, 2026 in Newcastle upon Tyne, England. (Photo by Annabel Lee-Ellis/Getty Images)

LB: Tino Livramento – 6.5/10

He caught the eye at times on both ends of the field.

CM: Sandro Tonali – 8/10

Tonali was a positive influence on both halves and was accurate with his passing. He managed to score his penalty in the shootout.

CM: Jacob Ramsey – 6.5/10

He earned possession back once and made two decent runs with the ball.

CM: Joe Willock – 6/10

Willock struggled to get a foothold in the game but made one good chance in the final third.

RW: Yoane Wissa – 6.5/10

He was not shy of having a strike at goal but failed to get his name on the scoresheet.

ST: Nick Woltemade – 7/10

Woltemade engineered some decent chances for others around him in the final third and has got an assist to show for his efforts.

LW: Harvey Barnes – 9/10

He was a constant menace in the final third and managed to score a brace for the Magpies today. Barnes also converted his penalty in the shootout and deserves to be named the man of the match.

Substitutes:

LB: Lewis Hall – 7.5/10

He made one good run with the ball and managed to convert his penalty.

RB: Lewis Miley – 7/10

Miley managed to shine at times on the right flank and scored his penalty as well.

LW: Anthony Gordon – 8.5/10

He scored the all-important equaliser in injury time and scored his penalty in the shootout.

CM: Joelinton – 7.5/10

Joelinton was a positive influence in the middle of the park.