Liverpool’s New No 2? Mamardashvili Eyes Alisson’s Throne After Kelleher Exit | OneFootball

Caoimhin Kelleher’s Farewell and the Goalkeeping Transition at Liverpool

Beyond the Backup Label

Liverpool has rarely paused to grieve the departure of a second-choice goalkeeper. Yet Caoimhin Kelleher was never your average understudy. His £18million ($24.3m) move to Brentford may seem routine in modern football finance, but the emotional reaction surrounding it tells a deeper tale — of a player who defied the typical backup narrative to carve out a reputation of substance and style.

Kelleher arrived from Cork’s Ringmahon Rangers in 2015 with promise, but not prestige. What followed was a steady rise into Ireland’s standout goalkeeper, a trusted custodian for club and country. Though he remained in the shadow of Alisson for much of his Liverpool career, he stepped out when called upon and never looked out of place.

Photo IMAGO

With only 25 Premier League starts across six seasons, it’s tempting to view his contribution as peripheral. But in truth, Kelleher’s presence often proved pivotal. His calm demeanour, sharp reflexes, and quiet confidence became integral whenever Liverpool’s No 1 was unavailable. He earned the mantle of the Premier League’s best backup goalkeeper — a moniker both complimentary and limiting.

Championship Contributions and Final Flourish

Kelleher’s timing, in both his saves and career moments, has always been notable. That he played a bigger part in Liverpool’s 2024–25 Premier League title win felt deserved. Injuries to Alisson opened the door, and Kelleher walked through with assured hands and unshakeable poise. He featured ten times during the title run-in — three appearances in the Champions League and seven in the Premier League — as Alisson recovered from a hamstring issue.

His standout performance came in the 2-0 Champions League triumph over Real Madrid. That evening under the lights, he denied Kylian Mbappe from the penalty spot and made a series of crucial saves to preserve the clean sheet. He showed again what many already believed — that he could be a No 1 elsewhere.

Even his mistake in the 3-3 draw against Newcastle United at St James’s Park became a talking point spun into affection by Liverpool supporters. “Without that draw, we wouldn’t have won the league at Anfield,” some joked, pointing to the reshuffled fixture list that ended so gloriously in front of the Kop.

But humour could not hide reality. “For years, he’s made it clear that he wants more,” the original piece from The Athletic noted, and rightly so. Sitting in Alisson’s shadow was never going to satisfy a goalkeeper of Kelleher’s ambition and ability. Brentford offers him the minutes he craves and a platform to prove he’s more than a reliable reserve.

Mamardashvili’s Moment Arrives

While Kelleher departs with admiration and applause, Liverpool’s attention turns toward his successor. Giorgi Mamardashvili, a £29million recruit from Valencia, is already in place. Though he remained in Spain last season, the Georgian is now poised to step into the Liverpool squad for pre-season under Arne Slot.

Mamardashvili is no stranger to expectation. His performances for Georgia at Euro 2024 caught widespread attention. Liverpool acted swiftly, aware they were not the only ones watching. There were whispers of Alisson interest from Saudi Arabia, and though that pursuit has cooled, contingency planning was a necessity.

At just 24, Mamardashvili is entering the most defining stretch of his career. He has been learning English, integrating into the club’s culture from afar, and mentally preparing for the competition ahead. He wants to play, not just participate, and while Alisson remains Liverpool’s No 1 for now, there is an unspoken inevitability to the transition ahead.

“Injury concerns over Alisson’s record persist,” notes the original report. Last season’s three-month layoff was not an isolated issue. Liverpool’s sporting director, Richard Hughes, understood the risks and retained three senior stoppers for depth. That gamble paid off.

Now, with Vitezslav Jaros eyeing a loan in one of Europe’s top five leagues and Harvey Davies stepping up as third choice, the structure is clear. Should Alisson suffer another setback, it will be Mamardashvili who takes the gloves.

A Future in Safe Hands

Liverpool believe Mamardashvili has the temperament, talent, and technical prowess to one day replace Alisson outright. He thrives in possession-based systems, where quick distribution and positional intelligence are key. His stint at Valencia may have been marred by inconsistency — they finished 12th in La Liga — but he was often let down by a struggling defence, not his own shortcomings.

In fact, the environment at Liverpool could play to his strengths. A higher line, fewer shots faced, and a more dominant team structure may allow Mamardashvili to flourish. The club views him as a project worth investing in and believes he will become one of Europe’s top stoppers.

Whether that transition happens this season or in the next few years will depend on performance, patience, and perhaps pragmatism from both player and manager. For now, Mamardashvili is expected to challenge, not displace. Alisson’s status remains intact, but his heir is no longer hypothetical — he’s here, waiting.

And that’s the great paradox of modern football’s goalkeeping hierarchy. Only one can start, but the depth behind must be of elite standard. Liverpool had that in Kelleher and hope to maintain it with Mamardashvili. The dynamic between them and Alisson will shape much of what unfolds in the new season.

Legacy, Loyalty and Looking Ahead

Kelleher leaves with five major medals and memories to match. His League Cup contributions in 2022 and 2024 were vital, even if he watched on for the 2019 Champions League and the 2022 FA Cup latter stages. His legacy is not in quantity of games, but quality of character and performance. He stood tall when Liverpool needed him most.

“Might have crumbled without their first-choice goalkeeper,” the article rightly stated. But they did not, and in many ways, that was down to Kelleher’s calming influence.

As Arne Slot begins his reign, decisions over who starts in goal will be as critical as any tactical tweak. Alisson is the proven champion, Mamardashvili the emerging contender. The balance of experience and potential is finely poised.

One leaves, one arrives, but the thread connecting them is clear — Liverpool have prioritised their goalkeeping future with the same rigour they have applied across the pitch.

Kelleher departs with dignity and gratitude. Mamardashvili steps forward with belief and ambition. And Alisson, still one of the finest in the world, remains the benchmark both must reach.

In the goalkeeping union, respect is paramount. For Liverpool, the changing of the guard has begun, but the standard will not drop. It never does.