Uruguay’s Four-Star Connundrum | OneFootball

Uruguay wear four stars above their crest, and while the symbol sparks debate in many corners of the football world, it also serves as a reminder that the sport’s history stretches far beyond the modern FIFA era.

Football, whether many realize it or not, existed long before FIFA came into being. Although the world’s governing body was founded in 1904, the earliest officially recorded international match took place in 1872, when Scotland faced off against England, and the first FIFA World Cup wasn’t held until 1930. Long before global tournaments were standardized, the game was already evolving across continents, especially at the club level.

The 1930 Uruguay World Cup champion team.

Before international football fully united under FIFA’s structure, Uruguay — a small South American nation that today numbers just over 3 million people — was already establishing itself as one of the strongest footballing countries in the world.

Uruguay rose to prominence between the 1910s and 1930s because it developed a highly competitive football culture earlier than most nations. While much of Europe was disrupted by war and constrained by amateur systems, Uruguay had organized leagues, intense club rivalries, and regular international competition that sharpened both skill and mentality. The country was playing meaningful football while others were still finding their footing.

The sport quickly became a key part of Uruguay’s national identity. Players were shaped by a culture that valued technical quality, tactical intelligence, and emotional resilience. When Uruguay finally crossed paths with European teams in the 1920s, they were not testing ideas, they were executing a refined, collective style that felt modern, controlled, and overwhelming. That early advantage, combined with a relentless will to win, allowed a small nation to define football during its formative years.

By the time Uruguay approached its first global triumph in 1924, La Celeste had already secured four South American Championships, what we now know as Copa América titles. Along the way, Uruguay also dominated a wide range of international friendlies, further showcasing the depth and quality of its players.

Uruguay at the 1924 Olympics.

When Uruguay stepped onto the world stage at the 1924 Olympics, it did so with a generation of players who were already ahead of their time. One of the most striking figures was José Leandro Andrade, the legendary “Black Pearl.” Operating from midfield, his grace on the ball, physical presence, and refined technique mesmerized spectators and forever altered how the role could be played.

Héctor Scarone was another standout, widely regarded as one of the greatest forwards of his generation. A legend at Nacional, Scarone also played for Barcelona and several Italian clubs, including Inter and Palermo, and later managed Real Madrid.

Then there was José Nasazzi, the benchmark for every great Uruguayan defender who followed. Calm, commanding, and fearless, Nasazzi embodied leadership. He was the defensive anchor and emotional core of Uruguay’s golden generation, setting the standard later followed by figures such as Hugo de León, Diego Lugano, and Diego Godín.

Under the guidance of these players, Uruguay dominated the pre–World War II era and secured three of its four historic stars.

Olympic Triumphs

It is crucial to understand that at the 1924 and 1928 Olympic Games, held in France and the Netherlands, football nations sent their strongest possible teams, what today would be called full senior squads. There were no age limits, and the Olympic tournament was widely regarded as the most prestigious international competition in football. At the time, these events functioned as world championships.

In Paris 1924, Uruguay faced a brutal path to the title. La Celeste defeated Yugoslavia, the United States, France, the Netherlands, and Switzerland in a straight knockout format that left no room for error.

Uruguay scored 20 goals and conceded only two across the tournament. Pedro Petrone, later a Fiorentina legend, finished as the top scorer with nine goals, further highlighting Uruguay’s attacking power.

The competition featured 22 teams from four confederations, with Uruguay claiming gold, Switzerland silver, and Sweden bronze. Participating nations included France, Italy, Spain, Belgium, Egypt, Hungary, and Ireland, making Uruguay’s triumph unmistakably global in scope and importance.

Netherlands 1928

Four years later, many of the same Uruguayan players returned for the Amsterdam Games, determined to defend their title. With 17 teams competing from five confederations, the format remained unforgiving, yet Uruguay once again rose above the field.

Their path included victories over the Netherlands, Germany, and Italy, before a dramatic final against Argentina. After a 1–1 draw in the first final, Uruguay prevailed 2–1 in the replay. The matches showcased the best of Río de la Plata football, with Argentina impressing through players such as Domingo Tarasconi, Manuel Ferreira, and Roberto Cherro. For Uruguay, Pedro Petrone scored four goals in the tournament, while Héctor Scarone added three.

The international press responded with admiration. European newspapers described Uruguay as faster, smarter, and more cohesive than any team they had previously encountered. Writers frequently highlighted how composed the players looked under pressure and how seamlessly they functioned as a unit.

After the 1924 Games, many outlets openly referred to Uruguay as the best team in the world. By 1928, the verdict was clear: their success was no coincidence, and it was confirmation that Uruguay were setting the standard for modern football at the time.

Hosting the First FIFA World Cup

Photo by Keystone/Getty Images

Uruguay’s Olympic dominance played a decisive role in FIFA awarding the country the right to host the first World Cup in 1930. The Uruguayan government committed to covering travel and accommodation costs for visiting teams, an offer no European nation could match during the economic hardship of the late 1920s.

The tournament also coincided with the centenary of Uruguay’s first constitution, turning the World Cup into a national celebration. With the construction of the Estadio Centenario and FIFA’s confidence in Uruguay’s footballing prestige and organizational ability, the decision was both practical and symbolic: the world’s first World Cup would take place where football was already being played at its highest level.

Notably, two sections of the Estadio Centenario are named after the cities where Uruguay dazzled the world: Amsterdam and Colombes, the Paris suburb where Uruguay won Olympic gold in 1924.

In the 1930 final, Uruguay once again defeated Argentina, winning 4–2 in a fiercely contested match. Many veterans of the Olympic teams were still present, led by Nasazzi. The victory marked Uruguay’s third world title in just seven years.

Two decades later, following World War II, a new generation led by Obdulio Varela, Juan Alberto Schiaffino, Alcides Ghiggia, and Roque Máspoli shocked the world again by defeating Brazil at the 1950 World Cup in one of the most iconic upsets in sporting history.

To put Uruguay’s achievements in perspective: in 1930 the country had fewer than 2 million inhabitants, and by 1950 the population was only around 2.4 million. Yet Uruguay captured three of the five major world titles contested during that era. The only “World Champions” at the time from 1924-1950 were Uruguay (3) and Italy (2).

Recognition by FIFA

The strongest support for Uruguay’s four stars comes from FIFA itself. FIFA’s historical records list the 1924 and 1928 Olympic football tournaments as competitions organized under its authority and recognized as the highest level of international football before the FIFA World Cup began.

“From my point of view, the issue is absolutely clear and should not generate any debate or controversy…Uruguay [is] a four-time world champion,” said Canal 4 Uruguay’s Eduardo Rivas. “Those Olympic Games already carried a clear definition: whoever won those tournaments, jointly organized by the International Olympic Committee and FIFA, would be recognized as the world champion of amateur football.

“Uruguay was world champion at the 1930 World Cup as well, and that tournament was also played under amateur conditions. The players who competed were amateurs, not professionals. I emphasize this point because some attempt to introduce confusion by arguing that the 1924 and 1928 tournaments were amateur competitions — but the same was true in 1930, during the first World Cup.”

FIFA statutes and official publications further acknowledge that Olympic football served as the de facto world championship during that period. Most telling of all, FIFA has consistently approved Uruguay’s use of four stars in its own competitions, something that would not be permitted if those titles were not officially recognized. Together, these records and long-standing practice confirm the legitimacy of Uruguay’s four stars.

A Never-Ending Debate

Despite the evidence, debate still surrounds whether Uruguay should be described as a four-time world champion.

“The FIFA World Cup as such began in 1930, which means that the stars Uruguay earns for that tournament should be two,” said Bolavip writer Martin O’Donnell. “Olympic victories are exactly what they are: Olympic gold medals. Those tournaments laid the groundwork, but the World Cup as a distinct, standalone competition begins in 1930.”

From a strictly FIFA World Cup standpoint, Uruguay have two titles. That fact is not disputed.

However, history did not begin in 1930. While modern audiences are often conditioned to measure greatness only through FIFA World Cup statistics, the reality is that Uruguay were crowned the best team in the world four times under the standards of their era.

Time has a way of fading memories, and the past is often overlooked by newer generations. That makes the four stars above Uruguay’s crest more than decoration. They are a statement of history, a reminder that long before football became globalized, Uruguay stood at the very top of the game.