Questions need to be asked of Michael Oliver after Anfield performance | OneFootball

Premier League explanation for Oliver’s Liverpool decision raises major concern

Referee controversy clouds Liverpool’s defeat to Manchester United

Liverpool’s 2-1 defeat to Manchester United at Anfield was painful enough, but the controversy surrounding referee Michael Oliver’s decision to let play continue during Alexis Mac Allister’s head injury has only deepened frustration. The Premier League later explained that Oliver “did not see the injury,” yet replays appear to show the referee standing only a few yards away from the incident.

Photo IMAGO

Liverpool’s fourth consecutive defeat in all competitions came despite a dominant attacking performance, with an xG close to three and 48 touches inside United’s box compared to their rivals’ 16. Cody Gakpo struck the post three times, Mohamed Salah and Alexander Isak missed gilt-edged chances, and Harry Maguire’s 84th-minute header condemned the reigning champions to another setback.

The opening goal, scored by Bryan Mbeumo inside 63 seconds, changed the tone of the contest. Yet the real controversy came in its build-up, when Mac Allister was struck on the back of the head by Virgil van Dijk’s elbow and fell to the turf requiring four stitches. Despite the midfielder’s clear distress, Oliver allowed play to continue, leading directly to United’s opener.

Sky Sports commentator Peter Drury relayed the Premier League’s reasoning, saying: “What we are getting from the [Premier League] Match Centre is that the referee didn’t see the injury and was therefore obviously not able to stop the game.”

Referee oversight sparks debate on player safety

Replays told a different story. Oliver was visibly close to the incident and appeared to glance in Mac Allister’s direction, yet opted to let play go on. The image of the Argentine lying on the ground as United surged forward summed up the wider issue: a failure of awareness at a time when player safety should be paramount, As reported by Liverpool World.

Photo IMAGO

If a referee suspects a head injury, the Laws of the Game require the match to be stopped immediately. The sight of Mac Allister later returning to play with protective headwear was evidence enough that this was no minor knock. The decision reflected poorly on the officials, raising questions about consistency and accountability within the Premier League’s refereeing standards.

Referees will make mistakes, but incidents involving head injuries are treated with heightened caution across football. When an official fails to act swiftly in such circumstances, it undermines confidence in the game’s commitment to protecting players.

Slot’s measured response amid growing frustration

Liverpool manager Arne Slot chose his words carefully after the match, declining to directly criticise Oliver but acknowledging the severity of the situation.

“I think the main thing we should do now, I should do now, is not complain, blame or do these kind of things. We could have done much better after Macca was on the floor, we should have done better,” Slot said. “But the healthcare of a player is something that is important and if a player needs to have four stitches, you would hope that everybody understands that he needs immediate treatment. But it didn’t happen.”

Photo IMAGO

Slot emphasised Liverpool’s integrity in such moments, adding: “We are not a team that goes to the floor pretending it’s a head injury to kill the counter-attack. That’s not who we are. We always are a fair team. So if a player of ours is then on the floor you would hope everybody would say, ‘It’s Liverpool, they don’t do these kind of things, so let’s blow the whistle.’”

While Slot refused to use the incident as an excuse, it is clear that the referee’s handling of the moment affected the match’s rhythm and outcome.

Carragher voices frustration over inconsistency

Former Liverpool defender Jamie Carragher shared his exasperation live on Sky Sports, pointing to recent inconsistencies in how referees handle head injuries. “I have been frustrated that players have taken advantage of that rule,” Carragher said. “There was an incident in the Arsenal game yesterday near the dugout, and the referee pulled it back. I am very surprised Michael Oliver hasn’t brought it back.”

Photo: IMAGO

Carragher’s comments echo a wider sentiment among players and fans alike that refereeing decisions have become increasingly erratic this season. For a senior official as experienced as Oliver, this lapse in judgment has added to a growing list of controversies involving Premier League officiating.

Liverpool’s focus now turns to recovery and reflection. Four consecutive losses have dented confidence, but their underlying performances particularly against United, show enough promise for optimism. Still, moments like Mac Allister’s injury remind everyone that football’s duty of care must come before competition.

Our View – Anfield Index Analysis

This feels like another chapter in a season defined by frustration and fine margins. The defeat to Manchester United hurts, but the manner of it leaves an even sourer taste. When a player suffers a head injury, the expectation is clear: the game stops. For Michael Oliver to miss that, especially when standing so close, feels inexcusable.

Fans understand that referees are human, yet this particular decision feels careless. Liverpool supporters have seen too many similar incidents this season where crucial moments have gone unchecked by officials. The Premier League’s explanation that Oliver “didn’t see” the incident simply does not sit right when replays suggest otherwise.

Supporters will appreciate Arne Slot’s dignified reaction, but his restraint mirrors the club’s professionalism more than the fans’ emotions. Many feel that accountability is missing in English officiating, that referees rarely face scrutiny for errors that alter major matches.

While the defeat itself cannot be pinned solely on this incident, the broader issue remains: consistency and player welfare must come first. For Liverpool fans, it is another example of frustration not just with the result, but with a refereeing system that appears detached from the reality on the pitch.