This Everton Player Is On The Wishlist Of Manchester United: Why The Toffees Should Renew His Contract | OneFootball

Everton’s steady climb back to form has shown their discipline, grit, and reliance on a few dependable players. They rarely make headlines but always deliver, and James Garner fits that description perfectly. The English midfielder drives Everton’s midfield with a silent authority on the field. He links play with purpose and adjusts his role to suit the team’s needs.

Since the Englishman joined from Manchester United in 2022, he has grown into a mature and intelligent player. He plays deep, pushes forward, or even fills in as a full-back. The 24-year-old’s adaptability has impressed fans across the league. Now, his progress has caught the eye of his former club.

Manchester United want to sign Everton midfielder James Garner

Turkish journalist Ekrem Konur reports that Manchester United have started exploring a move to bring Garner back to Old Trafford. The Red Devils want to strengthen their midfield next year. They see Garner as the ideal player for the holding role. Casemiro’s uncertain future and Manuel Ugarte’s inconsistent form have forced the club to rethink their midfield options.

In that situation, Garner, who has already played nearly 100 games for Everton, gives them both familiarity and reliability. His previous experience at the club would help him settle quickly if he returns to Old Trafford. Still, the Toffees aim to keep him.

David Moyes’ side is already holding talks over a new contract since his current deal runs until 2026, and his value keeps rising. The club continues to show ambition in other areas as well. We reported earlier that Everton must pay €20 million for Juanlu Sánchez and are one of the clubs monitoring Ansu Fati.

Should the Toffees make a move fast to renew Garner’s deal?

LIVERPOOL, ENGLAND – SEPTEMBER 29: James Garner of Everton in action during the Premier League match between Everton and West Ham United at Hill Dickinson Stadium on September 29, 2025 in Liverpool, England. (Photo by Michael Regan/Getty Images)

If Everton need to extend Garner’s contract demands, it needs quick but careful action. The Toffees cannot afford to lose such a reliable and versatile midfielder. He gives the team balance and flexibility across several roles. If they renew the defensive midfielder on a new contract, it secures a key player and sends a strong message to clubs like Manchester United.

If they sign him up early, they stop rumours and prove to the supporters that they plan to protect their best talent. The financial logic supports that move. The club has stabilised their finances after struggling with Profit and Sustainability rules in the past. If they do renew Garner’s deal, it should go with their strategy of smart squad building, as long as they keep wages under control.

Everton must ensure that the deal matches their long-term recruitment plans. However, Garner’s ability to play several positions makes him a vital part of the team’s future. Given his age and potential, offering him a new contract makes sense. Everton should make a decisive move fast before interest turns into actual offers.