Review Of The Summer Transfer Window Of Newcastle United: Did Eddie Howe Get His Cards Right? | OneFootball

Newcastle United underwent several twists in the latest summer transfer window of 2025. In the initial stages of the window, the Magpies wanted to sign some big names, but they all went to some other clubs and that made the supporters worry about whether their club still has the pull despite playing in the UEFA Champions League.

The biggest shock came when Alexander Isak publicly announced his desire to leave and was eventually signed by Liverpool in a record £125 million deal. As we previously reported, the deal proved to be a shock to the club and its supporters.

Early disappointment and questions

Isak’s departure left a void and dented squad morale. However, the real problem was the club’s failure to achieve early goals. This raised questions about whether the Magpies could really attract big players. All of this drama made the first part of the window bitter.

Late relief and new hope

As time started to run out, the club stepped up and completed some key deals. Anthony Elanga came in from Nottingham Forest, who promised pace and width in attack. The defence was strengthened with the addition of Malick Thiaw from AC Milan, and Jacob Ramsey from Aston Villa added life to the midfield. Competition in the goalkeeper position was increased by bringing in Aaron Ramsdale on loan from Southampton.

The last few days saw real action with the signings of Nick Woltemade from VfB Stuttgart and Yoane Wissa from Brentford. Notably, Wissa’s £55 million deal came through on deadline day, despite us reporting just a few weeks ago that Brentford didn’t want to let him go. Woltemade has been described by many pundits as a mix of Dimitar Berbatov and Harry Kane, which suggests he could be a long-term number nine.

In total, the club spent £253.6 million and sold £151.5 million, leaving a net spend of -£102.1 million. The investment was big, but Isak’s departure still weighs heavily on the club.

While the new faces have added depth and quality, early failures and the departure of the star striker left this window incomplete. That’s why it’s hard to give this transfer window more than a six out of 10. In our opinion, the club made strong improvements late, but losing a player like Isak will be a topic of discussion for a long time.