Breaking the Mold: When Underdogs Toppled Football Dynasties | OneFootball

For decades, many of the world’s top football leagues have been dominated by a few powerhouse clubs, creating dynasties that seem almost untouchable. But every so often, an underdog rises and rewrites history, ending long-standing streaks and capturing hearts along the way.

In Scotland, something unusual is happening. Hearts currently sit at the top of the Scottish Premiership, seven points clear and still unbeaten, putting them on track to potentially end a 40-year duopoly held by Rangers and Celtic. If their run holds, it would mark the first time since 1985 that a club outside the Old Firm has lifted the league trophy. To put this in perspective, long streaks of dominance are common in football, where leagues can be controlled by one or two clubs for decades before the status quo is broken.

Whenever an underdog defies expectations — like Leicester City’s shock Premier League win in 2016 — it captures attention worldwide and wins over both football purists and bettors looking for quick payouts from sportsbooks alike.

Many neutral fans in Scotland have now begun quietly cheering for Hearts. Here, we look back at other historic moments when clubs broke long-standing streaks and rewrote the rules of their leagues.

2024: Bayer Leverkusen Breaks Bayern Munich’s Hold

Photo by Dean Mouhtaropoulos/Getty Images

Bayer Leverkusen’s 2023–24 Bundesliga title was more than just a trophy, it transformed the identity of a club long known for near misses. Under Xabi Alonso, Leverkusen played bold, disciplined football, embarking on an impressive unbeaten run that finally ended Bayern Munich’s 11-year dominance. Their triumph stands as one of the Bundesliga’s most remarkable and refreshing championship stories.

2021: Sporting CP Finally Overcomes Benfica and Porto

Sporting CP’s 2020–21 league victory marked a turning point in Portuguese football. After nearly two decades without a title, the club returned to the top with a young, ambitious squad guided by Rúben Amorim’s tactical vision and rock-solid defense. By breaking the cycle dominated by Benfica and Porto, Sporting reestablished their winning identity and delivered one of the most emotional and unexpected championships in Portugal’s modern era. Sporting has since won the last two league titles.

2001: San Lorenzo Rises Amid Crisis

In 2001, a financially struggling San Lorenzo side, coached by Manuel Pellegrini, ended the reign of Boca Juniors and River Plate, who had traded Argentine league titles since 1998. Pellegrini led a squad that hadn’t been paid in six months to a record 13 consecutive wins, powered by talents like Leandro Romagnoli, Pablo Michelini, and Bernardo Romeo. Their success remains one of Argentina’s most inspiring underdog stories in an era where the country was in financial ruin.

2023: Liverpool Ends Nacional and Peñarol’s Dominance

From 2014-22, Nacional and Peñarol had swapped winning the Uruguayan league, while Liverpool mainly found success in shorter tournaments (Apertura and Clausura). That changed in 2023, when coach Jorge Bava implemented a modern, balanced style that finally broke the Old Guard’s hold, proving that strategy and organization could overcome tradition in Uruguay’s often predictable league.

1998: Chicago Fire Snaps DC United’s Reign

Photo by Jonathan Daniel /Allsport

When MLS began in 1996, DC United dominated the young league under Bruce Arena, led by Jaime Moreno, Marco Etcheverry, and John Harkes. By 1998, expansion side Chicago Fire, guided by Piotr Nowak and head coach Bob Bradley, finally ended United’s dominance. While DC United went on to win one more MLS Cup and two international trophies, Chicago’s breakthrough highlighted how new teams could disrupt a league’s early power structures, and made MLS execs breathe a bit easier that the whole parity thing could work.

2000/2001: Lazio and Roma Disrupt Serie A

Photo by Claudio Villa/Allsport

Photo by Claudio Villa /Allsport

The late 1990s and early 2000s saw AC Milan and Juventus dominate Serie A. In 1999-00, Lazio, led by Sven-Göran Eriksson, snapped an eight-year hold on the title by the Old Lady and the Rossoneri. A season later, AS Roma captured the 2000–01 Scudetto under Fabio Capello, with stars like Francesco Totti, Gabriel Batistuta, and Cafu leading the charge, giving Rome rare back-to-back league triumphs.

2002/2004: Valencia’s Two-Title Era

La Liga has traditionally been dominated by Real Madrid and Barcelona, with occasional exceptions like Deportivo La Coruña or Atlético Madrid. But the early 2000s belonged to Valencia, who won two league titles under Rafa Benítez. Their success was built on tactical intelligence, collective discipline, and precise teamwork, with players such as Roberto Ayala, Rubén Baraja, David Albelda, Pablo Aimar, and Vicente forming a unit capable of taking on Spain’s giants. During this period, Valencia also claimed the UEFA Cup, making it a remarkable three-season run.

1995: Blackburn Rovers’ Unlikely Premier League Triumph

Credit: Getty Images

When the Premier League began in 1992, Manchester United quickly established themselves as the dominant force, winning the first two titles. Yet Blackburn Rovers defied expectations in 1994–95, securing their first top-flight league crown since 1914 and their first major trophy in 67 years, following the 1927–28 FA Cup. Kenny Dalglish’s team clinched the championship on the final day despite a 2–1 loss at Liverpool, as Manchester United could only manage a 1–1 draw at West Ham. It’s worth noting that United would go on to win seven of the first 10 Premier League titles, with Arsenal taking the other two.