Everton £120,000 Star Back On Man Utd Radar: Can The Toffees Afford To Lose Him Now? | OneFootball

Everton could face a major test over their defence, with Manchester United again targeting the 24-year-old England international Jarrad Branthwaite. talkSPORT reports, as detailed by Goodison News, that United are preparing a fresh approach for Jarrad Branthwaite after tracking the centre-back for more than two years.

United previously saw two bids rejected in 2024, but their interest has returned as Harry Maguire, Luke Shaw and Lisandro Martinez near the end of their contracts. Branthwaite has strengthened his case quickly this season, starting all four Premier League matches for David Moyes and completing every minute.

Everton hold the cards. Branthwaite signed a five-year deal in July 2025, running to June 2030, so the club have no pressing financial reason to sell. Goodison News says fans remain unhappy after the £65 million sale of Iliman Ndiaye to Manchester City, while Everton are expected to demand a huge figure for their defensive prize.

Can Everton afford to lose Branthwaite now?

For me, the answer should be a firm no. His 2025-26 campaign tells you why United can smell an opportunity: two hamstring setbacks restricted him to 10 league appearances, seven starts and 682 minutes, although he still scored once against Tottenham and posted 58 clearances, six tackles, four blocks, three interceptions and 87% passing.

LIVERPOOL, ENGLAND – AUGUST 15: Jarrad Branthwaite of Everton looks on during the pre-season friendly match between Everton and OSC Lille at Hill Dickinson Stadium on August 15, 2026 in Liverpool, England. (Photo by Jess Hornby/Getty Images)

This season looks very different. Branthwaite has played 360 minutes from four starts, made 12 clearances against Bournemouth, produced eight clearances and two tackles against United, then helped Everton keep Tottenham out with six clearances in a 0-0 draw. Those numbers show a defender who has regained rhythm, physical confidence and the ability to carry heavy defensive responsibility week after week. Backup options cannot easily reproduce the same balance, pace and aerial strength.

Everton have every reason to hold firm

The July 2025 contract gives Moyes and the boardroom room to resist. A reported £120,000 weekly wage, a deal through 2030 and a release clause above £70 million leave United facing a serious financial test. Selling after the Ndiaye backlash would stir another fight with supporters, especially as Everton build a new identity at Hill Dickinson Stadium.

Branthwaite is a rare commodity being left-footed, homegrown, young and capable of anchoring a defence beside James Tarkowski. Everton have Michael Keane and Jake O’Brien for cover, but replacing Branthwaite’s quality would cost heavily. Moyes should keep the partnership intact and use it as the base for a top-half push. Even a huge United cheque shouldn’t change that.