
Anfield Index
·21 October 2025
Final Thoughts as Liverpool Suffer Huge Defeat to Man United

In partnership with
Yahoo sportsAnfield Index
·21 October 2025
With Liverpool looking to respond after a turbulent run of form, this clash with arch-rivals Manchester United carried enormous weight. Two historic clubs met under contrasting narratives — Arne Slot’s champions searching for rhythm and identity, while Ruben Amorim’s United arrived as organised disruptors with renewed confidence.
In a match filled with frustration, woodwork strikes, and fleeting flashes of promise, Liverpool’s disjointed attack and structural lapses were once again their undoing.
Liverpool XI
• GK – Giorgi Mamardashvili
• RB – Conor Bradley
• CB – Ibrahima Konaté
• CB – Virgil van Dijk (c)
• LB – Milos Kerkez
• CM – Alexis Mac Allister
• CM – Ryan Gravenberch
• CM – Dominik Szoboszlai
• RW – Mohamed Salah
• CF – Alexander Isak
• LW – Cody Gakpo
Florian Wirtz → Ryan Gravenberch (62’)
Curtis Jones → Alexis Mac Allister (62’)
Hugo Ekitike → Conor Bradley (62’)
Federico Chiesa → Alexander Isak (72’)
Wataru Endō → Mohamed Salah (85’)
Liverpool 0 – 1 Manchester United – Bryan Mbeumo (Amad Diallo) – 2’
Liverpool 1 – 1 Manchester United – Cody Gakpo (Federico Chiesa) – 78’
Liverpool 1 – 2 Manchester United – Harry Maguire (Bruno Fernandes) – 84’
• Possession – Liverpool 64% | Man U 37%
• XG – Liverpool 2.75 | Man U 1.34
• Total Shots – Liverpool 19 | Man U 12
• Fouls – Liverpool 8 | Man U 14
• Corners – Liverpool 9 | Man U 4
• Saves – Liverpool 2 | Man U 5
Tired of trying to second guess Slot, but hope he sees sense and Wirtz, Ekitike and Jones all start.–
An expectant Anfield crowd watched in shock as United struck almost immediately, with Bryan Mbeumo finishing a rapid counter after a misplaced Liverpool pass in midfield. From that point, Arne Slot’s men were forced to chase control — something that continues to elude them since the beginning of the season.
Without Trent Alexander-Arnold’s orchestration from deep, Liverpool’s buildup felt slow and uncertain. Conor Bradley tried to provide width, but transitions repeatedly broke down before reaching the final third.
Cody Gakpo hit the woodwork twice, coming closest to levelling the score as frustration began to spread from pitch to stands. Dominik Szoboszlai showed drive, though his influence was limited by a tactical role that again saw him drifting into full-back zones.
By halftime, Liverpool had dominated possession and territory but looked structurally unsure — full of motion yet devoid of method. The crowd was concerned and had every reason to be.
The restart brought renewed aggression and a clear instruction to pin United deeper. Mac Allister started to dictate more effectively, with Gravenberch supporting in advanced positions. Liverpool eventually found their reward through Gakpo after a raft of substitutions, who at last broke through with a smart finish after good work by substitute Federico Chiesa.
For a few brief minutes, it looked as though momentum had returned and maximum points may materialise. Yet once again, defensive frailty undid the effort of response. A corner, a lapse in marking, and Harry Maguire rose unopposed to nod United back ahead.
Slot’s subsequent substitutions — including Ekitike and Wirtz — failed to spark a final surge. Liverpool continued to push but failed to break down an inferior team once again, epitomising a night of missed chances and fine margins.
Gakpo, arguably Liverpool’s standout attacker, led the line with intent, yet his efforts were undone by a collective imbalance that continues to define the champions’ early season struggles.
This defeat marks a fourth successive loss for Liverpool in all competitions — a worrying sign for a team in transition and unsure of its potential. The structural uncertainty from back to front is glaring, with a lack of chemistry between the front line and midfield.
Szoboszlai’s constant redeployment to right-back highlights the absence of cohesion, while Mac Allister still searches for rhythm after a stuttering start caused by injury. Arne Slot’s system promises control, yet the execution remains hesitant and brittle under pressure.
Slot will know time and patience are necessary commodities, but in the Premier League, both are in short supply and the fanbase will not accept continuing losses.
Liverpool 2 – 1 Manchester United
Live