
City Xtra
·1 October 2025
Manchester City make loan decision on James Trafford amid transfer interest

In partnership with
Yahoo sportsCity Xtra
·1 October 2025
Officials at Manchester City have seemingly made their final decision around a potential loan exit for No.2 choice goalkeeper James Trafford.
Trafford’s situation has been one of the most-discussed subplots of City’s season so far, having been handed the gloves for the club’s first three Premier League fixtures before his role shifted dramatically following Gianluigi Donnarumma’s arrival on transfer deadline day to replace Ederson.
Since then, the Italian international has started in marquee fixtures against the likes of Manchester United, Napoli, and Arsenal, forcing James Trafford into the role of deputy and confirming his status as the club’s new back-up choice.
The 22-year-old had been tipped by some to leave the Etihad Stadium in January in search of more consistent playing time, with both Premier League and Championship clubs reportedly circling.
That narrative was somewhat further fuelled by Burnley manager Scott Parker, who described it as “a shame” that Trafford had fallen into a back-up role so soon after excelling at Turf Moor last season.
Yet Manchester City have long stressed Trafford’s importance to their long-term plans and while Donnarumma may now be Pep Guardiola’s undisputed first choice, the club remain conscious of the need to keep strong competition in place across all positions.
According to the information of Football Insider’s Pete O’Rourke, Pep Guardiola will not allow James Trafford to leave Manchester City on a loan agreement during the upcoming January transfer window.
While it has been suggested that his future at the Etihad Stadium was uncertain following the arrival of Gianluigi Donnarumma as a new No.1 between the posts, the report points to a belief within the club that the young Englishman still has a part to play under Guardiola.
City are said to be ‘eager’ to keep Trafford rather than sanctioning a loan, with manager Guardiola wanting two top goalkeepers that can push each other to improve, as such forcing the former Burnley man to stay and fight for his place.
Looking ahead, Trafford’s immediate focus will be on seizing the chances Pep Guardiola does offer him, likely in domestic cups or lower-profile league fixtures with the next opportunity possibly coming away to Swansea City in the Carabao Cup fourth round at the end of October.
Should Trafford impress, the pressure could even grow on Gianluigi Donnarumma to maintain his form, which is exactly the kind of competitive environment Manchester City’s coaching staff are keen to foster.
Beyond January, much will depend on Trafford’s patience. If he can balance development with limited game-time, he could be primed to step into a greater role over the coming seasons. However, should frustrations grow, speculation about a future loan or even permanent exit is certain to resurface.
Live
Live
Live