Player Ratings: Nico O’Reilly shines as Man City beat Arsenal in the Carabao Cup Final | OneFootball

Player Ratings: Nico O’Reilly shines as Man City beat Arsenal in the Carabao Cup Final | OneFootball

In partnership with

Yahoo sports
Icon: EPL Index

EPL Index

·22 March 2026

Player Ratings: Nico O’Reilly shines as Man City beat Arsenal in the Carabao Cup Final

Article image:Player Ratings: Nico O’Reilly shines as Man City beat Arsenal in the Carabao Cup Final

Nico O’Reilly Shines as Man City Beat Arsenal in the Carabao Cup Final

Manchester City reminded everyone how these occasions are navigated, controlling the narrative when it mattered most and leaving Arsenal with familiar questions. The Carabao Cup final at Wembley ended 2-0, yet the story sits in the details, small moments, big consequences, and a young player seizing his chance.

Match Overview and Key Moments

For 45 minutes, this felt cagey, almost tentative. Arsenal had control in patches, City probed without conviction, and Wembley waited. Then the game tilted.


OneFootball Videos


On 60 minutes, a routine delivery from Rayan Cherki should have been dealt with. Instead, Kepa Arrizabalaga spilled it, and Nico O’Reilly reacted quickest, stooping to head home. Four minutes later, the same name, same outcome, different route. Matheus Nunes delivered, O’Reilly arrived at the far post, and the contest was effectively over at 2-0.

From there, Manchester City did what seasoned winners do. They managed the tempo, closed the spaces, and never allowed Arsenal back into the contest.

Article image:Player Ratings: Nico O’Reilly shines as Man City beat Arsenal in the Carabao Cup Final

Photo: IMAGO

Man City Control and Arsenal Struggles

City’s performance after the break carried authority. The pressing became sharper, the passing more purposeful, and the movement far more difficult to track. Pep Guardiola’s side looked energised, playing with the urgency that had been missing in recent weeks.

Arsenal, by contrast, drifted. There was a lack of incision in the final third, and their midfield, while industrious, struggled to impose itself once City raised the intensity. The decision to stick with Kepa in goal proved costly, not just for the error but for the ripple effect it had on confidence.

James Trafford, at the other end, delivered when required. His early triple save kept City level and set the platform for what followed. Finals often hinge on these moments, and this one was no different.

Player Ratings Arsenal vs Man City

Arsenal Player Ratings

  • Kepa Arrizabalaga 3
  • Ben White 5
  • William Saliba 6
  • Gabriel 6
  • Piero Hincapie 4
  • Martin Zubimendi 6
  • Declan Rice 7
  • Kai Havertz 5
  • Leandro Trossard 5
  • Bukayo Saka 6
  • Viktor Gyokeres 5

Man City Player Ratings

  • James Trafford 8
  • Matheus Nunes 7
  • Abdukodir Khusanov 7
  • Nathan Ake 7
  • Nico O’Reilly 9
  • Rodri 7
  • Bernardo Silva 7
  • Rayan Cherki 8
  • Antoine Semenyo 8
  • Jeremy Doku 7
  • Erling Haaland 6

What This Means Moving Forward

For Manchester City, this felt like a reset. Not flawless, not vintage, but effective and, crucially, decisive. Guardiola’s fifth EFL Cup underlines a continued ability to deliver silverware even during transitional phases.

For Arsenal, the wait continues. Since the 2020 FA Cup, progress has been evident, yet moments like this highlight the final step still required. Control must become dominance, and dominance must translate into trophies.

View publisher imprint