Player Ratings: O’Reilly Shines as Man City Beat Newcastle 2-1 in Premier League Clash | OneFootball

Player Ratings: O’Reilly Shines as Man City Beat Newcastle 2-1 in Premier League Clash | OneFootball

In partnership with

Yahoo sports
Icon: EPL Index

EPL Index

·21 February 2026

Player Ratings: O’Reilly Shines as Man City Beat Newcastle 2-1 in Premier League Clash

Article image:Player Ratings: O’Reilly Shines as Man City Beat Newcastle 2-1 in Premier League Clash

Man City edge Newcastle to reignite Premier League title charge

In a season shaped by narrow margins and shifting pressure, Man City found both poise and persistence to defeat Newcastle 2-1 at the Etihad Stadium. The result trims the gap at the top of the Premier League table and sharpens the sense that the title race will not yield quietly.

Nico O’Reilly, thriving in a midfield role that recalls his academy days, delivered the decisive contribution. His opener, struck with conviction, set the tone. Lewis Hall responded swiftly for Newcastle, his effort taking a deflection on its way in. Yet O’Reilly rose again, this time to meet a precise Erling Haaland cross with a header that combined timing and authority.


OneFootball Videos


Haaland’s seventh assist of the Premier League campaign underlined his expanding influence. 

O’Reilly influence in decisive moments

City’s first half carried the authority of a side aware of its responsibilities. Rodri anchored, Bernardo Silva orchestrated, and O’Reilly ghosted into spaces that Newcastle struggled to monitor. His late stretch for a near third goal hinted at a performance played on instinct.

After the interval, the rhythm altered. Newcastle pressed higher, releasing Anthony Elanga and Anthony Gordon into space. City’s control wavered, composure tested by direct running and late deliveries. In stoppage time, Nick Pope ventured forward, causing brief alarm, but Gianluigi Donnarumma and his defence held firm.

The final whistle drew a roar that travelled beyond Manchester. In a Premier League campaign where psychological edges matter, this felt significant.

Newcastle resistance and fine margins

Newcastle’s display carried resilience. Hall’s equaliser rewarded ambition. Jacob Ramsey injected drive from midfield, while Malick Thiaw and Burn absorbed pressure after early uncertainty. Sandro Tonali struggled to dictate possession, and Joe Willock’s influence waned.

There were moments when Newcastle might have tilted the narrative. Gordon tested Donnarumma, Burn’s disallowed header prompted debate, and Harvey Barnes forced a late save. Yet against Man City, hesitation often proves costly.

Premier League implications at summit

For Pep Guardiola, the evening blended satisfaction and scrutiny. His decision to withdraw Ruben Dias at half time, mindful of a booking, proved prudent. Abdukodir Khusanov’s pace from the bench curtailed Elanga’s threat. City’s capacity to endure, even when rhythm deserts them, may define their pursuit of the Premier League crown.

Player Ratings

Man City

Gianluigi Donnarumma 7Matheus Nunes 6Ruben Dias 5Marc Guehi 7Rayan Ait Nouri 6Bernardo Silva 6Rodri 7Nico O’Reilly 9Antoine Semenyo 6Erling Haaland 7Omar Marmoush 6

SubstitutesAbdukodir Khusanov 7Rayan Cherki 6

Newcastle

Nick Pope 5Kieran Trippier 6Malick Thiaw 6Dan Burn 7Lewis Hall 8Sandro Tonali 5Jacob Ramsey 6Joe Willock 5Anthony Elanga 5Nick Woltemade 5Anthony Gordon 5

SubstitutesJoelinton 6Harvey Barnes 5

View publisher imprint