Aston Villa Face Challenge of Reintegrating Emiliano Martínez | OneFootball

Martinez finds comfort in Argentina duty

International breaks rarely hold much excitement for Premier League players, but for Emiliano Martinez they provide a welcome reprieve. Returning to Argentina, the World Cup-winning goalkeeper is surrounded by people who understand him best. He is revered at home — a leader, a talisman and a figure who embodies the national team spirit under Lionel Messi’s influence.

This September, the international pause arrived at just the right moment. Martinez had endured an unsettling few weeks at Aston Villa, with his future under Unai Emery thrown into sharp focus.

Deadline day disappointment

On 1 September, Martinez was waiting at Villa’s training ground for a phone call from Manchester United that never arrived. Despite being scheduled to fly to Argentina later that day, he lingered, hoping a transfer might still materialise. Instead, United turned their attention elsewhere, leaving Martinez stranded in an awkward position.

Villa staff, surprised by his presence, could see his growing frustration. The following day — his 33rd birthday — Villa publicly acknowledged him on their social media accounts, but privately the atmosphere remained strained. Sources have described the entire episode as “awkward” and left scars between player and club.

Photo IMAGO

Villa and Emery weigh reintegration

Villa still view Martinez as central to their plans. With Marco Bizot unable to convince in the 3-0 defeat against Crystal Palace, Emery and his staff want to restore Martinez to the side. Sources close to the player suggest he will approach the task professionally, though he must first overcome the disappointment of missing out on a high-profile move.

Argentina head coach Lionel Scaloni gave a positive assessment last week, stating Martinez was in good spirits while celebrating his birthday with the squad. Scaloni added that once the goalkeeper returned to Villa, his focus would inevitably shift back to club football.

Yet those around Villa acknowledge that some boundaries have been tested. A senior Premier League recruitment figure commented that Martinez’s desire to leave for a club not competing in Europe reflects poorly on both player and team ambition. Emery, who values discipline and unity, must now navigate the delicate process of reintegrating his goalkeeper into a group that was well aware of his transfer wishes.

Player power and Villa’s challenge

Martinez’s case is emblematic of a wider shift across European football. More players are forcing moves through absences, ultimatums and training ground stand-offs. From Yoanne Wissa’s switch from Brentford to Newcastle United to Alexander Isak’s departure from Newcastle to Liverpool, this summer underlined the leverage footballers increasingly hold.

For Emery and Aston Villa, the situation is clear: Martinez is their best option in goal and remains among the Premier League’s finest keepers. Dropping him weakens the side, but re-establishing trust within the dressing room is equally crucial. Football’s short memory will help — results often erase discontent — but how long Martinez chooses to stay at Villa Park is a question that lingers without a definitive answer.