Miguel Almiron return to Atlanta United not at all working out as hoped… | OneFootball

Miguel Almiron moved from Newcastle United to Atlanta United on 30 January 2025.

Almost exactly six years to the day (31 January 2019) when he moved in the opposite direction.

Some great business by Newcastle United in that transfer window, Lloyd Kelly also moved out, with the two transfers set to earn United around £30m in total and especially in PSR terms great business, as for PSR purposes almost all that money will be banked as profit in the 2024/25 accounts.

The move back to the USA also looked set to be a great decision for both Miguel Almiron and Atlanta United, it couldn’t have got off to a better start.

First game of the MLS season (Eastern Conference), Atlanta United hosting Montreal, a crowd of 65,520 turning up to see the return of Miguel Almiron.

He didn’t disappoint. Miggy was outstanding on his second debut for the club.

Atlanta United twice led, only for Montreal to level both times. Then came the moment, five minutes to go, Miguel Almiron setting up Mosquera to score the winning goal (see the official report below)!

However, things haven’t continued in quite the same way for both Miguel Almiron and Atlanta United.

Since 28 May 2025, Atlanta United have won only one MLS match, their record in the last 17 games has been one win, seven draws and nine defeats.

This is how the MLS Eastern Conference table now looks on 13 October 2025:

As you can see, only DC United are keeping Miggy and his teammates off the very bottom of the MLS Eastern Conference.

However, it is the big showdown on Saturday (18 October 2025), as the final round of matches in the regular league season sees Atlanta United at home to DC United. If the away side win, they swap places and Miguel Almiron and Atllanta United finish the season rock bottom of the Eastern Conference.

In his 30 MLS matches this 2025 season, Miguel Almiron has managed five goals and four assists.

It isn’t only the results that have fallen away dramatically.

Whilst 65,520 turned up for the first game and win of the season to see Miggy’s return, crowds have fallen as low as less than 40,000, some 26,000 less than for that Miguel Almiron return.

In his first spell at Atlanta United, Miguel Almiron was a machine when it came to direct goal involvements. Starting 65 MLS matches he had 41 direct goal involvements, scoring 22 and getting 19 assists. After that opening day win and assist for the winning goal, Miguel Almiron has not managed to add any more assists and has only scored three goals.

Obviously the blame can’t be only attached to the former Newcastle United player but certainly Miggy hasn’t been able to have anything like the kind of impact he did first time around at Atlanta United.

Hopefully Miggy and Atlanta can bounce back next season but I think fair to say as well, that Newcastle United eventually banking £11m from this Miguel Almiron (now aged 31) return to Atlanta United, is looking a cracking deal for NUFC.

On a personal note though, two big positives for Miguel Almiron since leaving St James’ Park.

Earlier this year Miggy received his Carabao Cup winners medal for his contributions in the competition in the earlier rounds before he left. Whilst Miguel Almiron and Paraguay have qualified for the 2026 World Cup finals.

Atlanta United official site – 23 February 2025:

’17s, you’ve done it again. Atlanta United recorded an attendance of 65,520, the third-largest crowd for a soccer match in the world on Saturday. The 5-Stripes took down CF Montréal 3-2, as new signing Emmanuel Latte Lath scored a brace in his competitive debut with the club. Both of his goals had 17s rocking, and you could truly here the force of north of 65,000 passionate supporters.

Fans had plenty of reasons to be in the building. A new head coach led a team with new signings all over the pitch, maybe none more energizing than Miguel Almirón, who dazzled in his return to Mercedes-Benz Stadium, assisting the winning/go ahead goal. As the lineups were announced, fans waited for No. 10’s name to be called. A roar erupted as Miggy’s smile showed on the Halo Board once again. Fans gave him a standing ovation as he left the pitch in the 99th minute. Bienvenidos a casa, Miggy.

ATLiens also got to witness a milestone for another club legend, as Brad Guzan made his 200th appearance for the club. Chants of “GUZZZ” echoed throughout the ground as the veteran captain came up with a few clutch saves down the stretch.

Latte Lath set the stadium ablaze twice during the match, but no sound could match the sound of the winner. Substitute Edwin Mosquera’s strike in the 85th minute proved the decider.