Newcastle United & 11 more clubs who shamelessly changed their badges for the worse | OneFootball

A club badge is a sacred part of any sporting team’s history, particularly in football where clubs have often kept the same crest for their entire existence.

It’s more than just a marketing ploy, or a space to fill a part of a shirt. A club’s badge is its identity, the first thing many people think of when discussing a club, the emblem that represents their lives from Friday to Sunday.

We’re not being at all dramatic here, either. We’re actually underselling it. The badge is the last bastion of tribalism. If you go changing that, you throw away years of history and upset a lot of fans – particularly the ones who have the old one tattooed to them somewhere.

Some sides just don’t get that, though, and don’t listen. At least for a bit. With that in mind, here are 12 examples of clubs ripping up the rulebook and changing their side’s badge.

Inter

In 2021, it was all change on the blue side of Milan. As well as ending a lengthy partnership with shirt sponsor Pirelli, Inter announced they would be adorning a new club crest.

Out was the gold detailing and the intricacies of the ‘FC’ and in was a soulless circle of lines, that looks more like the logo of an overpriced suburban restaurant. Not a huge change, but a terrible one.

Newcastle United

Less of a change for the worse, more a case of much ado about nothing.

Newcastle have unveiled their new badge but it’s opened up a game of spot the difference for everyone other than those most familiar with the old one.

They’ve gone big, explaining the change is “the culmination of more than two years of comprehensive consultation,” before citing consultation with “leading industry experts” and referencing their “world-class ambitions.”

They might not have shamelessly changed it for the worse, but they’ve certainly shamelessly bragged about what looks like a non-update to most neutrals.

Manchester City

After almost 20 years of their eagle design, City went back to a circular club crest in 2016, during Pep Guardiola’s first season at the club.

While it isn’t one of the worst re-designs ever, and they do have a history with the circular badge, it was a shame to see such a unique crest cast aside for something more brand-friendly and simplistic. We see right through you and your callbacks to the past, City.

Leeds United

Only Leeds – one of football’s most chaotic clubs – could pull something like this. In 2018, their owners announced the old badge would be replaced with a new design.

That design remains one of the worst badges you’ll ever see. ‘Leeds United’ was plastered along the top of the crest, with a fist punching a chest beneath. It looked like if you asked a teenager learning Photoshop for the very first time to pull together a new logo for the local gym.

To absolutely no surprise, it was rejected by fans and never adopted.

Juventus

One of football’s great crimes, this one.

Juve, whose storied history is proudly displayed through the form of their oval, striped emblem, committed the cardinal sin that was the badge change in 2019, and it remains one of the worst examples ever.

Out was the traditional, unique logo and in was a letter J. That’s it. The letter J. Soulless is an understatement. You sold out.

Aston Villa

Ahead of the 2023-24 Premier League season, Villa shelved their traditional shield crest and adopted a new badge.

You guessed it – it’s a circle.

It wasn’t bad, per se, but was incredibly boring. Lo and behold, they changed back to a shield just a year later.

Arsenal

Sticking with acceptable but slightly disappointing changes, Arsenal pulled the trigger on a big rebrand in 2002.

Out was the very traditional-looking shield, which they were unable to copyright, and in was a sleek, new take on it.

Credit to the Gunners for retaining key elements such as the shape and the cannon. That old badge was marvellous, though.

https://twitter.com/RobotCanary/status/1329192459491012608

Cardiff City

Juventus’ badge change was one of the greatest crimes, but it’ll never eclipse what went on at Cardiff from 2012 to 2015. Nothing ever will.

Owner Vincent Tan ushered in a new era for the club, changing the Bluebirds’ (!) traditional badge and home kit colours to red, to honour investment into the club from their Malaysian owners.

That is the sin of all sins. Needless to say it didn’t last and Cardiff were rightfully back in blue after three years, with a blue badge to match. The fact the owners actually stuck to their guns with it for that long, though, is ridiculous.

Columbus Crew

This one was a real shame.

MLS is still finding its feet in the global sphere of football, with people forgetting that the United States’ top-flight is still just barely 30 years old.

Badge changes and identity crises are a little more expected, therefore. But when the Columbus Crew ditched their incredibly unique ‘CREW’ badge, which pictured three soldiers marching out the shield, it was gutting. Especially upon learning that the new badge was a circle. Ugh.

Chicago Fire

A similar story to the crew, Chicago Fire adorned an incredibly unique, flower-like design until 2019, when the club went back to the drawing board.

Except they didn’t go to the drawing board. It instead looked like they went to Fiverr and paid someone with no interest in football to design a new logo.

That abomination lasted just two years before they rebranded again, to something closer to their original design.

https://twitter.com/fucksecre/status/1450458293953044483

West Ham

In a bid to simplify their design and look a little more sleek, West Ham tweaked their crest in 2016 to usher in a new era, as they waved goodbye to the Boleyn Ground and hello to the London Stadium.

It’s not terrible, but it could certainly be better. A decade on, the badge they left behind still feels more iconic.

Nantes

Taking inspiration from Turin, Nantes also waved goodbye to their own history in 2019 and copied Juventus in identifying themselves through a singular letter.

Out was a unique shield that honoured their domestic success through stars, their founding date and a ship that honours the city’s seaport and estuary. In was the letter N.

We don’t have the words.