No issue with either penalty in Celtic’s win over Motherwell | OneFootball

Dermot Gallagher agreed that both penalty calls in the Celtic’s 3-2 victory over Motherwell on Sunday were correct…

The Celtic team comes together at the final whistle during the Scottish Premiership match between Celtic FC and Motherwell FC at Celtic Park, on 5th October 2025. (Picture by Mark Runnacles Shutterstock)

Brendan Rodgers’ men were given a penalty for a handball during the first half of their crucial three points against a well-coached Steelmen side.

In the second half, Motherwell were then awarded a penalty following a VAR check on Marcelo Saracchi’s challenge on Tawanda Maswanhise.

Giving his view of the incident on Sky Sports, Gallagher said: “He just stands on his foot. He doesn’t mean to do it, but if you watch there, he just catches him. He is in possession of the ball, and he is going to gain the ball so VAR intervenes, penalty.”

Referee Calum Scott initially signalled for a goal-kick but changed his decision to a penalty after consulting the pitch side monitor on VAR Gavin Duncan’s advice.

Regarding Celtic’s penalty, when Callum McGregor’s shot struck Regan Charles-Cook’s arm, the former English Premier League referee said: “I think once your arm is up that high you are always going to get penalised.”

“The only doubt is, is it in the penalty area. You can see the referee’s position is perfect and can see it is in the penalty area. Penalty given on the field, correctly.”

Celtic will be aiming to use this international break as a chance to reset – and it’s fair to say it has come at the right time for the Scottish champions.

Motherwell were excellent at the weekend and it was refreshing to see a Premiership side come to Celtic Park and take risks in possession and play with real bravery.

Celtic v Motherwell Scottish Premiership 05/10/2025. Apostolos Stamatelopoulos 9 – Motherwell celebrates his leveler during the Scottish Premiership match between Celtic and Motherwell at Celtic Park, on 5 October 2025. Photo Raymond Davies PSI

At times, the visitors cut Celtic wide open. But we did deserve to win the game and despite being in turmoil on the pitch as well as off it, the players reacted well to going 2-1 down.

With another international break upon us, Celtic will return to action a week on Sunday with a trip to Dens Park to face a Dundee side that were hammered 4-0 by bottom side Aberdeen as Jimmy Thelin’s side at long last got a first Scottish Premiership win of the season.

Conor Spence

Readers of The Celtic Star and indeed all Celtic supporters joining the Celtic Pools Weekly Lottery and paying by direct debit will be able to claim a free stadium tour worth £18.50.  This promotion will run from now until the 20th October 2025. Click on image to join.

More Stories / Latest News

No issue with either penalty in Celtic’s win over Motherwell

Oct 7 2025, 8:25

Celebrating Jim Craig who made his Celtic debut 60 years ago today

Oct 7 2025, 7:00

Celtic confirm General Sale for must win Europa League clash

Oct 6 2025, 22:03