The Price of Accountability – Celtic needs Executive Redesign and Fan Culture Reality Check | OneFootball

THE PRICE OF ACCOUNTABILITY. Colin Dempster on why Celtic Needs an Executive Redesign and a Fan Culture Reality Check…

LASK vs Celtic, Linz 25 August 2026 – UEFA Champions League, play-off, the disappointment of Luke McCowan, Reo Hatate and Kasper Hogh. GEPA pictures/Manuel Binder/ IMAGO

In the immediate, white-hot aftermath of Celtic’s catastrophic 5-1 capitulation against LASK in Linz, I wrote a piece under a headline that choice words did not dictate, but reality demanded: TOTAL ABDICATION. It was a phrase intentionally chosen for its dual meaning—to reflect the absolute structural surrender we witnessed on the pitch, and to directly challenge the disconnected, unaccountable ruling class currently residing in the Parkhead boardroom.

1st March 2026; Ibrox Scottish Premiership the Rangers versus Celtic; Chris McKay and Michael Nicholson of Celtic arrive ahead of the game. Vagelis Georgariou

The fallout from that piece was entirely predictable. In modern football’s knee-jerk online echo chamber, offering a deep, structural critique often gets you misread. After my initial tactical analysis of the club’s corporate blueprint, some reactionary elements of the fanbase hastily labelled me a “board apologist.”

Let this piece leave no room for ambiguity: they had me entirely wrong.

I stand firmly by every syllable of my conviction. Michael Nicholson and Chris McKay must go. If they possess a shred of professional dignity and respect for the historic institution they oversee, they should resign. If not, they must be fired.

Businessman, Dermot Desmond, tees off on the second hole on day one of the Alfred Dunhill Links Championship 2025 at The Old Course on October 02, 2025 in St Andrews, Scotland. (Photo by Luke Walker/Getty Images)

Therefore, I implore Dermot Desmond to step forward, heal this growing rift, and do the right thing for our football club. As the custodian holding the ultimate power at Celtic PLC, the responsibility to break the silence and steer us out of this crisis stops with him.

The 5-1 disaster in Austria was not an isolated tactical anomaly; it was the inevitable sporting consequence of an isolated corporate strategy. For years, the day-to-day operations and financial mechanisms have been delegated to a CEO and CFO who view the club strictly through a fiscal lens.

3rd May 2026; Easter Road, Scottish Premiership, Hibernian versus Celtic; Brian Wilson, Michael Nicholson and Chris McKay of Celtic. Photo Vagelis Georgariou

While McKay manages vast cash reserves and balance sheets, the squad has been left systematically exposed on the European stage.

Yet, as the dust settles on the Linz disaster, a deeply disturbing trend has emerged within our own support that requires an urgent reality check. Overnight, a toxic minority of the fanbase descended into personal, anonymous vitriol, choosing to scapegoat individual players.

Luke McCowan of Celtic reacts after the match LASK v Celtic, UEFA Champions League, Play Off Round, Second Leg, Football, Raiffeisen Arena, Linz, Austria – 25 Aug 2026Linz Raiffeisen Arena. Photo Michael Zemanek/Shutterstock IMAGO

The abuse grew so severe that Luke McCowan—a lifelong Celtic supporter playing for the club he loves—was forced to deactivate his social media entirely to protect his peace.

Let us be completely clear: there is a distinct, unyielding boundary between analysing sporting professionalism and enacting personal cruelty.  McCowan’s cameo off the bench was a footballing nightmare, but targeting his character from behind a fake username crosses a line that no true Celtic fan should ever step over.

Cameron Carter-Vickers of Celtic and Luke McCowan of Celtic. LASK v Celtic, UEFA Champions League, Play Off Round, Second Leg, Football, Raiffeisen Arena, Linz, Austria – 25 Aug 2026Linz Raiffeisen Arena: Photo Michael Zemanek/Shutterstock

No player steps onto a pitch intending to fail. When we confuse legitimate tactical accountability with anonymous bullying, we diminish the soul of our club.

If we genuinely want to restore this club to its rightful standard and safeguard its heritage, we must learn from this disaster. Tearing down individual players fixes nothing.

True reformation requires an executive redesign at the absolute summit—a leadership model that finally bridges the icy divide between corporate finance and footballing reality. Dermot Desmond has the power to install that model.

Peter Lawwell, Chairman of Celtic, Dermot Desmond, Non-Executive Director of Celtic, and Michael Nicholson, CEO of Celtic, are seen in attendance prior to the Premiership match between Celtic FC and Rangers FC at Celtic Park on March 16, 2025. (Photo by Ian MacNicol/Getty Images)

We do not need more detached spreadsheet administrators. We need visionary, football-first leadership possessing both corporate gravity and an intrinsic understanding of what the green-and-white jersey demands.

1989: Portrait of Paul Elliott of Pisa eats an ice cream in Pisa, Italy. Photo: Ben Radford/Allsport

1989: Paul Elliott relaxes at home in Pisa, Italy. Photo Ben Radford/Allsport

The blueprint for that recovery exists. Imagine a boardroom led by Paul Elliott CBE as Chief Executive Officer. Elliott is a man who knows the weight of the Parkhead expectations as a former Scottish Footballer of the Year, yet his modern resume boasts elite-tier administrative gravity as the Vice-Chairman of Charlton Athletic and a Special Advisor to the English FA.

Celtic players Henrik Larsson and Ramon Vega celebrate winning the League Title after the Scottish Premier League game against St Mirren at Celtic Park. Photo: Tom Shaw /Allsport

Pair his structural governance with someone like Ramon Vega as Chief Financial Officer—a Treble-winning icon who holds a degree in banking and finance from Zurich and commands multi-million-pound global asset firms.

Bringing in individuals of that caliber is entirely within Celtic’s financial reach, and for men who have already built independent wealth, the motivation would be prestige and passion, not a corporate paycheck.

An Elliott-Vega partnership would instantly heal the rift with an alienated support, replacing corporate isolation with elite footballing pedigree and global financial acumen.

Writing these critiques gives me no satisfaction. Like every supporter, I long for the days where my column is an untainted celebration of beautiful football and boardroom harmony. But true love for an institution means holding it to the standard it deserves.

It is time for the toxicity to stop, for the executives to be replaced, and for Dermot Desmond to act.

Colin Dempster

NEW BOOK LAUNCH FROM CELTIC STAR BOOKS…Celtic in the Fifties in two volumes, available to pre-order now…

Celtic in the Fifties by Matt Corr, in two volumes, both published on 4th September 2026 by Celtic Star Books. Click on image to order.

Quick Tip – Add Celticshorts.com as your ‘Preferred Source’ on Google News for quick access to the Celtic content you value the most. It takes just a few seconds and you’ll notice the difference straight away! – Click HERE….Hail Hail!

Click to join Celtic Pools