Everton Will Not Let Their 23-Year-Old Player Leave in January: Why Is It the Right Decision? | OneFootball

Everton stand at a point where clarity matters more than noise, and the club’s direction continues to take shape under the guidance of manager David Moyes. The atmosphere around Goodison shows an awareness of change, but the club wants to avoid rushing into decisions that could unsettle the core of the team.

Earlier reports revealed that Everton do not plan to recall Harrison Armstrong this season. The club prefers continuity instead of sudden reshuffles. The emphasis stays on building steadily while keeping firm control of key players of the project.

Everton’s stance on Jarrad Branthwaite

Now, journalist Fraser Fletcher has reported that Everton have sent a clear message to clubs circling Jarrad Branthwaite during his absence, including Manchester United. Everton have stated clearly that they will keep the English centre-back in January, even though he has missed three months of action.

Everton have dismissed suggestions of a mid-season sale because the club views him as central to their long-term plans. Under David Moyes, the focus shifts to building a defensive unit that stays settled over multiple seasons, with Branthwaite at the heart of that plan. The new contract he signed in July supports this idea, giving him higher wages and firm recognition.

Moyes has also openly called the 23-year-old untouchable, even as he continues his recovery. People continue to discuss the possibility of a release clause, but no credible source confirms that one exists. Everton, however, value him at around £70 million or more, which tells interested clubs that the discussion will not be simple. The Toffees also reportedly want to sign Nicolas Jackson in the summer of 2026, and that is another sign that the club plans carefully and thinks ahead.

Why is keeping Branthwaite the correct call?

LIVERPOOL, ENGLAND – AUGUST 09: Jarrad Branthwaite of Everton during the pre-season friendly match between Everton and AS Roma at Hill Dickinson Stadium on August 09, 2025 in Liverpool, England. (Photo by Jan Kruger/Getty Images)

Keeping Branthwaite gives Everton a defensive anchor who can grow as the squad develops. His traits bring calmness at the back, as he reads situations early and steps into duels with purpose. That balance helps the team stay organised and avoid unnecessary pressure.

If Everton build around a centre-back with that presence, it will help Moyes because true stability begins in defence. If the Toffees go on to sell him in January, it would create a gap that no quick signing could realistically replace, especially with Everton still reconstructing their squad.

The defender’s commitment to the new contract shows that he sees long-term value at the club. The 23-year-old will return from injury and reflect their trust with steady performances. So, Everton are moving patiently with measured additions and belief in young core players. If the club keeps their faith in Branthwaite, it will be a right step in that direction and protect the identity they want to build.