Marcus Rashford vs Luis Diaz – Analysing the best option for Barcelona | OneFootball

Barcelona’s summer plans took an unexpected hit when Nico Williams changed his mind at the last minute. After it looked like he was coming to Camp Nou, he chose to stay at Athletic Club instead, signing a massive 10-year deal.

This move left Barcelona scrambling for options, and now two big names have come up on their radar: Marcus Rashford and Luis Diaz.

Both Rashford and Diaz bring different qualities and challenges to the table. For Barcelona fans hoping to see new faces in attack, it is important to look at what each player offers and what problems might come with trying to sign them.

Money matters: Can Barça afford either star?

First, let’s talk about the money. Barcelona are in a tough spot with their finances and need players willing to lower their wages to fit the club’s budget.

Thankfully, both Rashford and Diaz seem open to reducing their salaries if it means they get to play for Barcelona. But that doesn’t solve everything.

Luis Diaz would be expensive. (Photo by Stu Forster/Getty Images)

Diaz has a contract with Liverpool until 2027, which makes him more expensive. His value is around €80 million, which is a big price tag for Barcelona.

If he pushes for a move, which many believe he will, it could help bring the price down a bit. Still, it would be a big investment.

On the other hand, Rashford is valued lower, at around €40 million. His situation at Manchester United is not great right now. The club has even taken away his number 10 shirt, a clear sign they don’t see him as part of their plans.

United would prefer to sell him, but if Barcelona wait, there is a chance they could get him on loan, saving money upfront.

Signing Rashford would also give Barcelona a marketing boost in the English-speaking world, which could bring in extra income off the pitch.

Performance and playing style: Who fits better?

Looking at how both players are performing now, Diaz is clearly in better shape. The Colombian winger is reliable and improving year after year.

He scores goals, helps the team press high up the pitch, and supports his full-back on defence. His current form makes him a safer bet for Barcelona if they want immediate results.

Rashford has struggled for form in the last few seasons. (Photo by Michael Steele/Getty Images)

In the 2024/25 season, the Colombian scored 17 goals and provided eight assists in 50 games across all competitions.

Rashford, on the other hand, has struggled over the last two seasons. He had a rough time at Manchester United and didn’t shine during his loan at Aston Villa either, where the club decided not to buy him for €46 million.

He has also had a dip in performance, having scored 11 goals and nine assists last season.

One good thing about both players is their versatility. They can play on either wing or even as a central forward. Over the years, both have proven they can score and change games, which is exactly what Barcelona need.

Conclusion

In the end, both Diaz and Rashford have qualities that could help Barcelona. Diaz offers consistency and work rate, but he comes with a higher transfer fee.

Rashford is cheaper and has the potential to grow into a superstar again, but he’s a risk because of his recent struggles.

At present, it is true that Barcelona need a forward, and a fresh start for the Englishman could revitalise his career under Hansi Flick. A gamble, yes. However, if there is a chance of loan, Barcelona must explore.

Barcelona must decide if they want to pay more for a player performing now or gamble on Rashford turning his career around.