Huddersfield Town claim made over £1m Plymouth Argyle deal - he's leaving 'a little to be desired' | OneFootball

FLW's Terriers expert weighs in on Bali Mumba's time so far in West Yorkshire

This article is part of Football League World's 'Terrace Talk' series, which provides personal opinions from our FLW Fan Pundits regarding the latest breaking news, teams, players, managers, potential signings and more…

Mid-February in League One is rarely a time for grand conclusions, yet it is invariably a moment for assessment.

Six matches into a new era, with systems still settling and hierarchies still forming, early signings are placed under the microscope. At Huddersfield Town, few arrivals have generated as much conversation as Bali Mumba.

Recruited from Plymouth Argyle for a reported £1 million fee and tied down until 2029, Mumba’s arrival was positioned as both statement and solution.

The 24-year-old had been one of League One’s outstanding performers just two seasons ago, instrumental in Argyle’s title-winning campaign and recognised as the division’s Young Player of the Season.

His pace, positional flexibility and proven output from wing-back made him an attractive profile for a Huddersfield side seeking greater thrust down the left flank.

Yet excitement on paper does not always translate seamlessly onto grass. Social media reaction among Terriers supporters has been mixed - some encouraged by flashes of dynamism, others frustrated by inconsistency in his final delivery.

The timing has not helped. Mumba signed expecting one managerial vision under Lee Grant, only for swift change to alter the tactical framework around him with the arrival of Liam Manning. Since then, he has been asked to adapt quickly.

The raw numbers are steady rather than spectacular: one assist in five league matches under the current head coach, consistent minutes, and performance ratings that reflect competence more than dominance.

In a side that has won three and drawn one of those six league fixtures, his presence has coincided with results - but not yet with the kind of decisive attacking returns that justify headlines.

Early Huddersfield Town verdict on Bali Mumba after £1m Plymouth Argyle transfer

For Huddersfield supporters, therefore, the debate is nuanced. There is recognition of Mumba’s athletic profile and pedigree, tempered by a sense that greater end product is required.

Football League World spoke to in-house Terriers expert Graeme Rayner for his early assessment of Mumba.

“I would say the jury's still out, I think, is the short answer,” Rayner told FLW.

“I think he's got loads of potential and he's played every minute of Liam Manning's five league games, which we've won three, lost one and drew one, and that can't be underestimated when Mickel Miller is fit and could play for the first few of those. We also had Ruben Roosken available as well (before he left for Oxford United).

“He's clearly someone that the new manager likes. I think he does bring something as a wing back/sort of left midfielder that we were lacking in terms of pace and directness.

“I think sometimes his final ball leaves a little to be desired and defensively, he can still be a little suspect.

“Our last home game, last Saturday at home to Blackpool, in the first half, he, like many of the team, were nowhere near good enough and he was one of a handful of players that were maybe being singled out by Town fans.

“But second half, I thought he was superb. He really stepped up when we came from 2-0 down to rescue a point, and probably had the game gone on for another five or ten minutes, I think we'd have won.

“So, I don't think you can underestimate his contribution, but have we seen the best of him? 
I don't think so yet. He's certainly been okay, but I think there's more to come from him.

“It's really early in his time, and it must be very difficult for him having signed expecting Lee Grant to be his manager.

"Lee Grant managed one game and then he's had five league games with the new guy and a quarter-final in the Vertu Trophy, so six games under the new guy.

“So, I think we have to give him a little time to bed in and don't expect too much for him, but I think that he's probably got a bright future. I mean, he's still, he's only 24. I think we've got a lot potentially to come from him.

“I'm still happy about the signing, I just think he can deliver more. I mean, he's got one assist in those five league games - I think we need more from him there.

“But, let's give him a bit of time to adjust to having a new manager after one game and only having played a handful of games for us.”

Bali Mumba hasn't had instant Huddersfield Town impact, but time is on his side

Six games is insufficient to settle any long-term argument, but it is enough to outline themes.

Mumba has immediately altered Huddersfield’s athletic profile on the left: he carries the ball aggressively, commits defenders and offers width in a system that demands relentless running from its wing-backs.

In matches where Town have controlled territory, his forward thrust has stretched opposition lines and created transitional opportunities.

Where scrutiny remains is in refinement.

During Plymouth’s promotion season, his explosiveness was inseparable to end product - six goals and seven assists in a title-winning side.

At Huddersfield, the creative numbers have yet to mirror that output. For a £1 million acquisition in a promotion-chasing context, those margins stand out.

However, there are mitigating factors. Managerial upheaval disrupted the initial transition and so, tactical responsibilities have shifted midstream.

At 24, Mumba remains within a developmental arc rather than at its peak. The coaching staff’s willingness to trust him with heavy minutes suggests internal conviction that his ceiling remains high.

Ultimately, the early verdict is best framed as progressive rather than transformative. He has contributed to positive results and provided qualities that were previously scarce. The next step is changing endeavour into decisive output.

If that evolution happens, the narrative around his arrival will shift quickly from cautious optimism to a clear endorsement. For now, Huddersfield possess a player with demonstrable League One pedigree who is still calibrating to new demands.